Jan 4, 2025 · 28 min

What's Wrong With Our Schools?

About this episode

This YouTube transcript from Milton Friedman’s “Free to Choose” series features a discussion on education reform. Friedman advocates for a voucher system, arguing that parental choice and market competition would improve educational quality. Opponents, including teachers’ union representatives, counter that this would disadvantage low-income families and create a two-tiered system. The debate centers on the role of government in education, the effectiveness of public schools, and the potential benefits and drawbacks of market-based reforms. The discussion also explores the differences between public and private education, using examples of successful and failing schools.

Chapters

  1. Part 1 · 0:00
  2. Part 2 · 5:01
  3. Part 3 · 10:00
  4. Part 4 · 15:00
  5. Part 5 · 20:00
  6. Part 6 · 25:00

Transcript

Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.

Part 1 · 0:00

[0:00]Welcome back everyone for another deep dive with us. It's great to be back. Today we're gonna be looking at education. Oh yeah, a big one. It is a big one. For sure. And we were gonna be taking a look at a 1980s episode of Milton Friedman's Free to Choose.

[0:15]Yes. And this one is about education. And just to give everybody a little background, Milton Friedman was a very well known economist. Right. And I guess kind of a libertarian. Free markets. Free markets. Yeah. Individual liberty. Yep. And so he had this show called Free to Choose and this is one of the episodes from that.

[0:39]It's interesting how these things come back around. Like all the things that they were debating in the 80s are still things that we're debating now. Right. It's interesting too because he starts out this episode by contrasting two high schools.

[0:51]All right. One is Hyde Park High School in Boston. Okay. And it shows some of the problems that they were having there. Which were? You know, just I think under resourced. Yeah. They were having some security issues. Not a lot of parent power in that school.

[1:11]Right. And then he contrasts that with Weston High School. Okay. Which is in a wealthy suburb of Boston. Right. And it's like this beautiful campus. Yeah, the kids are all doing science projects and going to the football game. Yeah. And so it's this really stark contrast that he's setting up.

[1:29]But he's setting up this idea of control. Right. Like who has control over the education? And so this is kind of where I wanna pause and ask our listeners to think about the schools in their local communities. Right. Do you see any of these same kinds of?

[1:48]Disparities. Disparities? You know, are there schools that are really well funded? Mm-hmm. Maybe in more affluent areas. Right. And then other schools that are struggling. That are under-resourced. Yeah, and how does that make you feel? Yeah.

[2:01]You know, one of the things that Friedman points out is this idea that we used to have this kind of idyllic vision of the one room schoolhouse in Vermont. Right, yeah. Where parents had a lot of control. Right. Over their kids' education. Yeah.

[2:15]And so how much control do you feel like you have over your kids' education now? Right, and that's where he's going with this, is he wants to set up this idea that parents should have more control. More control. Over their kids' education. Right.

[2:29]And he thinks that the public school system, as it exists now, doesn't really allow for that. Right. So what are some of the criticisms that he has of the public school system? Well, he thinks that the public school system is too bureaucratic.

[2:43]Right. That it's not really set up to meet the needs of individual students. Right. And that it's basically failing a lot of kids. Yeah, and I think especially low-income families. Yeah, and so he sees that as a real problem because he says we're spending all this taxpayer money on this system that's not really working.

[3:04]Right. And he sees that as a form of injustice. Right, yeah. Because the people who are most affected by it are the people who can least afford to send their kids to private schools or find other alternatives. Exactly. So his solution to this is a voucher system.

[3:22]Right. And essentially what a voucher system would do is it would give parents money that they could then use to send their child to any school. Any school that they want. That they want, whether it's public or private. Public, private charter.

[3:35]Right. So he's saying that that would create competition among schools. Competition is good. Right, and that would then lead to. Would lead to better quality. Better quality. More innovation. Right, and more choices for parents. More choices for everybody.

[3:50]Exactly. Yeah. But of course. This is a very controversial idea. Extremely controversial. And so in the episode, he talks to a variety of people. He does. Who have different perspectives on this. Yes, yes, he talks to teachers. Right. Union reps.

[4:07]He talks to other economists. Yeah. Education experts. Right. School administrators. Mm-hmm. All sorts of people. And they have a lot of concerns about this idea of a voucher system. Yeah, they do. So what are some of those concerns that they raise?

[4:22]Well, one of the big concerns is that private schools would just cherry pick the best students. Right. You know, the kids who are already doing well. Right. The kids who come from families that are, you know, supportive of their education. Right.

[4:34]And they would leave the public schools to deal with all the kids who are, you know, maybe struggling. Maybe they have learning disabilities or behavioral problems or whatever. And so that's what they call cream-skimming. Right. Right. They're skimming off the cream of the crop and leaving the public schools with, you know, everybody else.

[4:52]Right. And they're concerned that that would actually make the inequalities in the system even worse. Right, because then you would have this

Part 2 · 5:01

[5:01]kind of two-tiered system where the private schools are getting better and better and the public schools are- And they're struggling even more. Right. And so it's interesting because, you know, Friedman's whole thing is about choice. And freedom.

[5:14]Right, but his critics are saying, well, is it really choice? If only certain people have the means to actually exercise that choice, you know? If you can't afford to send your kid to a private school, then what good is a voucher to you? Right.

[5:30]And it's not just about money. No. Right. I mean, it's also about- It's also about information. Information. You know, do you know what schools are out there? Do you know how to evaluate them? Do you have the time to, you know, go visit them and talk to the teachers and all that kind of stuff?

[5:46]Right, and so I think- So it's not as simple as just, you know, throwing money at the problem and saying, okay, now everybody has choice. Exactly. It's more complicated than that. So there's a lot to unpack here. There is. And we're gonna take a break.

[6:00]And when we come back, we're gonna delve into some more of the arguments for and against this voucher system. Oh, yeah. It feels good. We'll be right back. And another concern they brought up, you know, is that this could actually lead to more segregation in the schools.

[6:14]Yeah, if people are able to choose schools based on- Right, like their religious beliefs or, you know, the racial makeup of the school or the socioeconomic, you know, background of the students. So, you know, that's a real worry, is that this could actually make things more segregated.

[6:32]Right, and so it's not just about, you know, the kids in the schools. It's also about- The community. The community. Right, like how would this impact, you know- Yeah, how would it affect- Property values. Property values. Transportation. How about, you know, access to extracurricular activities?

[6:50]Yeah. All of those things. All those things. And then, you know, another thing that they brought up is this idea that, you know, our parents really equipped to make these decisions. To make informed decisions about education. About their kids' education.

[7:03]Right. You know, do they have the expertise, the knowledge to really know what's best for their kids? And, you know, they're saying, well look, we have professional educators who have, you know, spent years studying this, and they're the ones- Who should be making these decisions?

[7:20]And I think, you know, it goes back to that point about information. Like, do parents have access to- The right information. The right information to be able to make these choices. Yeah, and are they, you know, being given unbiased information?

[7:36]Right. You know, is it, are they being influenced by, you know, marketing campaigns, or political agendas, or whatever? Yeah. So it's a complicated issue. So it's not just about choice. It's also about making sure that people have the information they need to make.

[7:50]Informed choices. Informed choices. Yeah. Yeah, okay. And then, you know, another thing that they talked about is poverty. Right. You know, like, how does that factor into all this? Right. You know, because a lot of the problems that we see in education are really rooted in poverty.

[8:05]Yeah, like kids who are coming to school hungry. Right. Kids who- Kids who are, you know- Dealing with trauma at home. Kids who don't have stable housing. You know, all those kinds of things. Out of that. And so they're saying, you know, a voucher system is not gonna fix those problems.

[8:24]It's not gonna magically make poverty go away. So are we just putting a band-aid on a bigger problem? Right, is it just a way to kind of, you know, make ourselves feel better? Avoid the real issue. Right, yeah. So that's a, you know, a big concern.

[8:41]So they're not saying that choice is bad. They're just saying that we need to be careful- We need to be mindful. About how we implement it. Of the unintended consequences. Right, yeah. Okay, so Friedman also, in this episode, points to some specific examples of programs that he thinks are doing things right.

[9:02]Okay. One of them is the Inner City Scholarship Fund in New York. And this is a program that provides scholarships to low-income students. Okay. To attend private schools. Right. And he says that these schools- Are doing a great job. Are doing a great job.

[9:18]The kids are. The kids are thriving. Thriving. They're outperforming- They're outperforming their peers. Their peers in public schools. Yeah. And he says this is proof- That proof that choice works. Choice works. Yeah, okay. And he also talks about Harlem Prep.

[9:33]Okay. Which was a storefront school that was started in the 60s. Okay. And it was very successful. Okay. They had high graduation rates. Yeah. The kids were going on to college, but then it was eventually absorbed into the public school system.

[9:51]Okay. And then it declined. Oh, wow. Yeah, so he uses that as an example of how bureaucracy can stifle innovation. Stifle innovation.

Part 3 · 10:00

[10:00]Yeah. So he's saying that- He's saying that when you have these kind of independent schools that are free from- The constraints of the bureaucracy. Right. They can be more innovative. Yeah. They can be more responsive. Yeah. To the needs of students.

[10:15]To the needs of students and to the needs of parents. Right. Right. And so he sees that as- As a positive thing. As a positive thing. Yeah. Yeah. But then, of course, he also acknowledges that- That there have been. That there have been cases where choice hasn't worked out so well.

[10:32]Right. And one of the examples that he gives is- The LUMROC experiment. The LUMROC experiment in California. And this was a program. Yeah, back in the 70s. Yeah. They tried a voucher system. Yeah. And it didn't- And it didn't really work out.

[10:46]Really work out the way they hoped. The way they hoped. Yeah. Yeah. And so I think, you know, what's interesting about that is that- It shows that it's not a simple solution. Right. You know? Just because you give people choice. Just because you give people vouchers.

[10:58]Doesn't mean that. Doesn't mean that- Everything's gonna be great. Everything's gonna be magically fixed. Right. And so I think, you know, that's an important caveat to keep in mind- Oh, it keeps me in mind. As we're thinking about these issues.

[11:10]Because it's not a black and white issue. Right. It's very nuanced. Yeah. Okay, so we've been talking a lot about K through 12. Mm-hmm. But Friedman also has some thoughts on- Higher education. Higher education. Yeah. And he's not a big fan.

[11:24]He is not. Of state-funded colleges and universities. Yes, he's not. So why is that? Well, he thinks that they're- Yeah. Basically a subsidy for the wealthy. Okay. He says that, you know, lower income taxpayers are essentially paying for the education of people who are gonna go on to earn higher incomes.

[11:44]Right. So he sees that as a form of regressive taxation. So he's saying it's basically a transfer of wealth. Right, from the poor. From the poor. To the rich. To the rich. Wow. Yeah, and so he thinks that- We should move away from that system.

[11:58]Okay. And instead have a system of loans. Okay. Loans are responsible for- For their own education. For their own education. Okay. Yeah. And I think, you know, that's a very controversial idea. Very controversial. But it's one that's worth considering.

[12:12]It's worth thinking about. Yeah. Yeah. And so, you know, what are the arguments against that? Well, one of the big arguments against that is that loans create a barrier. Yeah. For low income students. Especially if you're already struggling to make ends meet.

[12:27]Right. And so it's an idea of taking on tens of thousands of dollars of debt. Can be very daunting. Yeah. Yeah. And it might deter you from even going to college in the first place. Right. Yeah. So it's interesting because, you know, Friedman's whole thing is about- Individual responsibility.

[12:45]Individual responsibility. Yeah. But- His critics are saying- But they're also societal benefits to education. Right. You know? Yeah. An educated workforce. Benefits everybody. Benefits everybody. And they're saying, you know, the government has a role to play- Right.

[13:01]In making sure that- Everybody has access. Everybody has access. Has access to education. To education. Yeah. And it's interesting too because, you know, he talks about how- Yeah. The government shouldn't be subsidizing- Right. Things that- That primarily benefit- The wealthy.

[13:18]The wealthy. Yeah. But his critics would say, well- Well, hold on a second. Yeah. The government subsidizes all sorts of things- Right. To not benefit corporation. To not benefit wealthy individuals. You know? Tax breaks. Yeah. Subsidies for- Yeah.

[13:34]You know, oil companies. Right. All that kind of stuff. Right. So why are we picking on education? Right. Why is that the one that we're saying, Oh, well- Yeah. You know? Yeah. That's too much government involvement. Right. You know? Yeah. So it's a complicated issue.

[13:47]So it's not just about, you know, individual responsibility, it's also about- Societal responsibility. Societal responsibility. Yeah. Yeah. So this is where- Yeah. We can start to think about- Yeah. How these ideas play out. In our own community.

[14:01]In our own community. Right. So, you know, what's the landscape of higher education like- Yeah. In your community? Are there a mix of public and private? Yeah. Do you have community colleges? Community colleges, yeah. You have. State universities.

[14:15]The universities, yeah. Private universities. And how affordable are they? Right. You know? Yeah. Are there scholarships available- Yeah. For low-income students? Yeah. Are there, you know, programs to help- To help people? People pay for college?

[14:29]Yeah. And I think, you know, one of the things that Friedman talks about- Yeah. Is that- Yeah. He thinks that- Yeah. Students should be more responsible for- Right. Paying for their own education. Right. But he also says that- But he also- They shouldn't think that- Everybody should go to college.

[14:44]Everybody needs to go to college. Right. Yeah. And I think that's an interesting point because we have this- We have this kind of- Yeah. Assumption in our society. Yeah. Everybody has to go to college. Everybody has to go to college. To be successful.

[14:57]To be successful. And Friedman's saying- And he's saying, well-

Part 4 · 15:00

[15:00]Yeah. Maybe not. Maybe not. Maybe there are other paths- Right. To success. Like trade schools? Like trade schools. Apprenticeships. Apprenticeships, yeah. Yeah. You know? And so, I think, you know, that's something worth thinking about. Yeah.

[15:14]What are the options in your community? Yeah. For people who don't want to go to college. Yeah. Or who can't afford to go to college. Right. You know? To get the opportunities for them. To get the skills they need. To get the skills they need.

[15:26]Yeah. To get good jobs. To have a good life. Yeah, and I think, you know, this is where we can start to think about- Yeah. How all of these ideas that we've been talking about- Right. Connect back- To our own lives. To our own lives. To our own communities.

[15:39]To our own communities. Yeah. Right? So, let's think about vouchers for a moment. Okay. One of the things that Friedman talks about- Yeah. Is parental control. Right. He thinks that parents- Are the best judges. Oh, okay. Of their kids' needs.

[15:54]More control over their kids' education. Yeah. But, as we've been discussing- But as we've discussed- Yeah. That raises some- That raises some- Equity issues. Equity issues. Yeah, like, are we really empowering all parents equally? Right. Or are we just empowering- Yeah.

[16:13]The parents who are already- Already privileged. Privileged and well-informed. And well-informed. Yeah. Think about the parents in your community. Do they all have equal access? To information. To information about schools. About the different options- Right.

[16:27]That are available. Would they be able to navigate- Right. A choice system? A complicated choice system. Right, sure. Especially if they- Especially if they face language barriers. Like if they- Or if they have limited time. Lack transportation.

[16:41]Or if they, you know, just don't have the resources to, you know, do all the research and the legwork that's involved. So it's not just about giving people choice. It's also about making sure that they have the support. The support they need.

[16:54]They need, yeah. To actually make use of that choice. To make informed choices. Yeah. And then of course- And then of course there's the issue of- There's the issue of funding. Funding, yeah. Right, if we're gonna have a voucher system, how do we make sure- That all of the schools- That all of the schools are adequately funded?

[17:11]Right, because- If public schools are losing students- Right. That means they're losing funding. Right. So how do we make sure- And so Friedman's argument is that- Competition will- Competition will- It forces schools to become more efficient.

[17:28]Right, but his critics worry- That it could lead to a race to the bottom- Yeah. Where schools are cutting corners- Yeah. To save money. And so then they're not providing a quality education. The quality education. Right. And so I think, you know, this is a really important- Point to consider.

[17:47]Consideration. Because it's not just about money, it's also about- It's also about the quality- The quality of the education. Of the education. Right. And so I think, you know, as we were- And then we're thinking about it. Thinking about all these issues.

[17:58]These issues. It's important to acknowledge the complexity. The complexity. Yeah. It's not a simple issue. It's not a simple issue. There's no easy answers. There's no easy answers. And so- And so we need to be- We need to be careful. About embracing- Yeah.

[18:14]Simple solutions. Simple solutions. Simple solutions. Yeah. Okay, so we've covered a lot of ground today. We have. We've talked about- We've talked about vouchers. Vouchers. We've talked about choice. It's the case. We've talked about the role of government in education.

[18:28]Yeah. All sorts of things. And so now I want to bring it back. Yeah. To that. Think and act locally. Think and act locally theme. Theme. Yeah. So what does all of this mean? For you. For you in your community. In your community. In your community.

[18:44]Yeah. So what are the strengths and weaknesses- Of your local school system. Of your local schools. Right. What are the demographics? What are the socioeconomic factors? Socio-economic factors at play. At play. And most importantly, what can you do?

[18:58]What can you do to get involved? To make a difference. To make a difference. Yeah. So are there- So are there school board meetings? School board meetings you can attend. That you can attend. Yeah. Are there local organizations that are working, that are advocating for you?

[19:13]On these issues. Education reform. Right. Are there parent groups that are- Yeah. That are- Trying to improve their schools. Trying to improve their schools. And I think, you know, it can feel overwhelming. It can feel overwhelming. To think about, to think about tackling- These big systemic issues.

[19:32]But remember that even small actions- Even small actions. Can make a difference. Can have a ripple effect. Yeah. So start by having conversations. Talking to your friends. With your friends and family. Yeah. Your neighbors. Your neighbors. Share what you've learned.

[19:47]Share what you've learned from this deep dive. From this deep dive. Right. Yeah. You know- Go to a school board meeting. Volunteer at a local school. Volunteer at a local school. Right. You know? Yeah.

Part 5 · 20:00

[20:00]Get involved. Get involved in your community. In your community. And I think, you know, one of the things that- One of the things that really struck me- Yeah. About this episode- Yeah. Is that Friedman uses these very vivid examples- Right.

[20:13]To illustrate his points. Like the two high schools. Like the two high schools. Right. You know? And it's such a powerful- Yeah, it's such a powerful- Reminder that- Reminder that these abstract debates about policy- Right. Have very real consequences- Yeah.

[20:30]For people's lives. For students' lives. Yeah. Right? And I think he does a really good job. He does a really good job. Yeah. Using storytelling. Of making these ideas. To make these complex ideas- Relatable. Relatable. Right. And whether you agree with him or not- I think it's important to- To at least engage with his ideas.

[20:49]Engage with his ideas. And think about- Yeah. You know what they mean. What they mean. For you. For your- Your community. Yeah. And so I think, you know, one of the things that he's really trying to do- Yeah. In this episode is to get people to think differently.

[21:03]Is to challenge the status quo. To challenge the status quo. Right. And I think, you know- He does a good job of that. He does a good job of that. Yeah. Even if you disagree with his conclusions- Right. I think it's important to at least consider- Consider his argument.

[21:16]His friend's argument. And I think, you know, one of the things that he's really advocating for- Is for people to- Is for- Think of their education. Proactive. Yeah. Right. To be more engaged- Yeah. In the process. In the process. Yeah. And I think that's something- That's something we can all agree on.

[21:35]We can all agree on. Yeah. Regardless of- Regardless of- Our political beliefs. Political beliefs. Or our- Yeah. Economic philosophy or whatever. So, as we wrap up this deep dive. Right. I wanna leave you with a few key takeaways. Right. First, education is not one size fits all.

[21:53]Right. Different students have different needs. Right. Different communities have different needs. Different communities have different resources. Right. Different challenges. And so we need to be mindful- We need to be mindful of that. Of that as we're- Since we're designing- Our education systems.

[22:07]Our education systems. Yeah. Second. Yeah. Don't be afraid to challenge the status quo. Right. Just because something has always been done a certain way. Doesn't mean it's the best way. Doesn't mean it's the best way. Yeah. And I think, you know, Freeman is a really good example of that.

[22:23]He's a great example of somebody who was not afraid to challenge conventional wisdom and to say, Hey, maybe we need to rethink how we're doing things. I think, you know, that's a really valuable- That's a really valuable- Perspective to have.

[22:40]Perspective. Right. And finally- Finally. Remember that you have a voice. Right. Get involved in your community. Get involved. You know, attend those school board meetings. Yeah. Talk to your elected officials. Talk to your elected officials.

[22:54]Support organizations. Support organizations that are working to improve education. To improve education. Yes. Yeah. And I think, you know, the future of education. The future of education. Yeah. Depends on- Depends on- Engaged citizens. Engaged citizens.

[23:10]You who are willing to think critically. To think critically. Ask tough questions. And demand better. And demand better for our kids. For our kids. So we hope this deep dive has given you some food for thought. Some food for thought. And inspired you.

[23:25]And inspired you. To take action. To take action. So thanks for joining us. Thanks for joining us. Until next time. Until next time. Keep learning. Keep learning. Keep questioning. Keep questioning. And keep diving deep. And keep diving deep.

[23:40]But we've covered a lot of ground today. We have. We've talked about vouchers. We've talked about choice. We've talked about the role of government in education, all sorts of things. And so now I wanna bring it back. Yeah. To think and act locally.

[23:55]Think and act locally theme. Theme. Yeah. So what does all of this mean for you in your community? For you in your community. So what are the strengths? Weaknesses. Of your local school system. Of your local schools. Right, what are the demographics?

[24:10]What are the socioeconomic factors at play? And most importantly, what can you do to get involved to make a difference? To make a difference, yeah. So are there school board meetings you can attend? That you can attend. Are there local organizations that are working?

[24:24]They're advocating for education reform. On these issues, right? Are there parent groups? Yeah, that are trying to improve their schools. They're trying to improve their schools. Yeah. And I think it can feel overwhelming. It can feel overwhelming.

[24:37]To think about tackling these big issues. These big systemic issues. Right, but remember. But remember that even small actions can have a ripple effect. Yeah, so start by talking to your friends. With your friends and family. Your neighbors share what you've learned from this deep dive.

[24:56]You know, go to a school board meeting. Volunteer at a local school.

Part 6 · 25:00

[25:00]Volunteer at a local school. Right. Right. Get involved in your community. In your community. And I think one of the things that- One of the things that really struck me about this episode was how Friedman uses these very vivid examples to illustrate his points.

[25:14]Like the two high schools. And it's such a powerful reminder that these abstract debates about policy have very real consequences for people's lives. For students' lives. Yeah. Right. And I think he does a really good job of using storytelling to make these complex ideas relatable.

[25:32]Relatable, yeah. And whether you agree with him or not, I think it's important to at least engage with his ideas and think about what they mean for your community. Yeah, for your community, yeah. And so I think one of the things that he's really trying to do in this episode is to get people to think differently.

[25:49]To challenge the status quo. To challenge the status quo. And I think he does a good job of that. Even if you disagree with his conclusions, I think it's important to at least consider- Consider his arguments. His arguments. And I think one of the things that he's really advocating for is for people to be more proactive.

[26:04]To take ownership of their education. Right, to be more engaged in the process. And I think that's something we can all agree on. That's something we can all agree on. Right. Yeah, regardless of our political beliefs or our economic philosophy or whatever.

[26:18]Right. So as we wrap up this deep dive- I wanna leave you with a few key takeaways. Right. First, education is not one size fits at all. Different students have different needs. Yeah. Different communities have different needs. Different communities have different resources, different challenges.

[26:36]Right, and so we need to be mindful of that as we're designing our education systems. As we're designing our education systems, yeah. Second, don't be afraid to challenge the status quo. Just because something has always been done a certain way doesn't mean it's the best way.

[26:51]And I think, you know, Friedman is a really good example of that. He's a great example of somebody who is not afraid to challenge conventional wisdom and to say, hey, maybe we need to rethink how we're doing things. And I think that's a really valuable perspective to have.

[27:03]It's a really valuable perspective, yeah. And finally, remember that you have a voice, get involved in your community, you know, attend those school board meetings. Yeah, talk to your elected officials, support organizations that are working to improve education.

[27:16]Right, and I think the future of education depends on engaged citizens like you who are willing to. Think critically, ask tough questions, and demand better for our kids. So we hope this deep dive has given you some food for thought and inspired you to take action.

[27:30]Thanks for joining us. Thanks for joining us. Until next time, keep learning, keep questioning, and keep diving deep. And keep diving deep.

Related