US Funding of EU Tech Censorship
About this episode
The Foundation for Freedom Online reports that U.S. taxpayer money is funding organizations involved in the EU’s online censorship regime. Specifically, 23 U.S.-funded entities are either signatories to the EU’s Code of Practice on Disinformation or actively participate in the “digital observatory” system that monitors online platforms. These organizations have collectively received over $15 million in government grants. This effort is viewed by some as a “transatlantic flank attack” to circumvent limitations on censorship in the U.S. by influencing American tech platforms through European regulations like the Digital Services Act (DSA). The DSA enables European censorship laws and provides U.S. “disinformation researchers” access to data from social media platforms and allows for continued speech suppression.
Chapters
Transcript
Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.
Part 1 · 0:00
[0:00]Hey everybody and welcome back to the deep dive. You know, today we're gonna be looking at something that might seem kind of far away from our little corner of Southeast Houston, you know, Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena. But trust me, this is something that could really have an impact on what we're seeing and saying online, right here at home.
[0:16]Absolutely. We're talking about online censorship and specifically how American tax dollars are actually being used to fund these organizations that are involved in these censorship efforts over in Europe. Yeah, you might be thinking Europe, what does that have to do with me?
[0:30]But you gotta remember the internet has no borders. Exactly. And decisions that are made across the pond, you know, can easily ripple out and affect all of us. For sure. And that's exactly why we're doing a deep dive today. We're looking at an investigative report from the Foundation for Freedom Online.
[0:44]The FFO. Yeah, the FFO, that's right. And the report's called 23 US-funded Organizations Drive the EU's War on Tech Companies. Catchy title. It is catchy. And we're gonna be unpacking some pretty surprising facts, like how much money these organizations are getting and who's really pulling the strings behind the scenes.
[1:01]Yeah, so let's talk about the EU. They have something called the Digital Services Act. Ooh, the DSA. The DSA, that's right. It's basically their attempt to regulate content on these big American tech platforms like Facebook, Google, the one formerly known as Twitter X.
[1:16]So wait, are they coming for our cat videos? Is that what we're worried about here? Not quite, although I'm sure some people would argue that there are already enough cat videos out there. That's true. The DSA is really mainly focused on what they consider misinformation and hate speech.
[1:32]And here's the thing. The EU can actually hit these companies with some pretty hefty fines if they don't play by their rules. So there are some serious teeth to this DSA thing. So where do these American organizations fit in? Like how are they involved?
[1:45]Well, the EU also has what they call a voluntary code of practice on disinformation. Oh, interesting. Now I say voluntary with a pretty healthy dose of skepticism because it's quickly becoming mandatory for these tech companies to operate in Europe.
[2:00]So they could be legally obligated to censor content that the EU finds problematic. So less of a suggestion and more of a do this or else. You got it. Now the FFO report identified 23 US funded organizations that are playing a key role in all of this.
[2:16]Some are what they call signatories, meaning they endorse and they legitimize the EU's code of practice. Others are what you might call enforcers. They're actively working to identify and target content that they deem harmful. And get this, some organizations are actually doing both.
[2:31]Yeah. They're both signatories and enforcers like NewsGuard. Oh yeah. You know the ones that put those nutrition labels on websites. Right. Some people see that as just a way to blacklist certain sources. Well and it's a valid concern when you look at the fact that NewsGuard received $750,000 from the Department of Defense.
[2:47]Wow. And they have advisors that are connected to the NSA, the CIA and the State Department. So they're not only endorsing these EU censorship efforts, they're actually actively working to implement them through these things called digital observatories.
[3:01]Hold on, digital observatories. That sounds like something out of like a sci-fi movie or something. It does, doesn't it? But picture it like a neighborhood watch. But for the internet, there are these EU backed groups that are tasked with monitoring these online platforms for anything they consider a harmful narrative.
[3:17]So NewsGuard is part of that. They're right in the thick of it, yeah. So it's not just some fringe groups pushing this. We're talking about like established players. Yeah. With some serious connection. Big time. And it doesn't stop there. Oh no.
[3:29]Remember the global disinformation index we talked about? Yeah. They're taking aim at the wallets of media outlets they don't like. How are they doing that? So they created this exclusion list that's meant to be used by advertisers. Okay. And the goal is to financially cripple those news sources that don't toe the line.
[3:46]So it's like a do not fund list. Exactly, a do not fund list. Wow, that's really aggressive. And this organization's getting US funding too? Yep. They receive $330,000 both directly from the State Department and through the National Endowment for Democracy.
[3:59]Wow. It looks like a pretty tangled web here. Yeah, it really is. And it gets even more interesting when you start looking at organizations like Bellingcat. Right. Which is this open source intelligence group that's actually been praised by the US intelligence community.
[4:12]And they've gotten funding from the National Endowment for Democracy. Okay. They're also knee deep in these digital observatories helping shape what information gets flagged. It's interesting how even Agents France Presse, the world's oldest news agency is involved in EU disinformation monitoring.
[4:28]And they've received millions from the US government including the Department of Defense and USAID. It's wild. Okay, so we've kind of unmasked some of the players here. Now let's talk money. How much are we talking about here? All right, so brace yourself.
[4:39]Okay. Because these 23 organizations have collectively received over $15 million in government grants and awards. I just wanna repeat that for our listeners, $15 million of American taxpayer money has gone to organizations that are pushing for online censorship in Europe.
[4:56]And that's just what we know about. Right. There could be even more funding flying under the radar.
Part 2 · 5:00
[5:00]So what does all of this mean for us here in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena? What does this say about the priorities of the US government? I mean, we're sending millions of dollars overseas to potentially limit online speech. Right. But we have people here at home that are struggling with things like infrastructure and education.
[5:17]It raises some interesting questions for sure. It does. So welcome back to the deep dive. Before the break, we were talking about how those US tax dollars are being funneled to these organizations that are involved in these online censorship efforts over in Europe.
[5:29]And we left off with a pretty big question. Yeah. How could this transatlantic censorship strategy actually directly impact what we see and say online here in the US? Well, that's the million dollar question, isn't it? Think about it this way.
[5:41]These EU regulations, they're like a big incentive for companies to just censor everything. Right. Just to be on the safe side. Because they don't wanna risk those big fines. Exactly, they don't wanna mess with that. And remember, these companies, they're global.
[5:53]Right. It's a lot easier for them to just have one set of rules for everybody than to try to tailor things to different countries. So you're saying that even if something is perfectly legal to post here in the US, it could still get taken down if it violates the EU's stricter rules.
[6:09]That's definitely a possibility and we've already seen it happening. I mean, remember when Elon Musk resisted those censorship demands in Brazil? Oh yeah, he stood his ground. He did. Refused to take down some content and then Twitter. Or X now.
[6:20]X now, yeah, they got banned in the whole country. The entire country. It's crazy. It is and it's a really powerful example of how these foreign governments can put the squeeze on these tech giants. Right. And it really highlights that potential for a chilling effect on free speech.
[6:35]It's like a domino effect. If companies start censoring to avoid trouble in one place, it sets a precedent that can easily be replicated somewhere else. Oh absolutely. And that's what makes this transatlantic connection so worrying. Okay. The EU is essentially setting a global standard for online censorship.
[6:51]Wow. And if it works there, what's to stop it from spreading to other countries? Including the US. Especially the US. Especially when you consider that some of the key players pushing this are American organizations. It's true. It's almost like a back door for US disinformation researchers to get what they want indirectly.
[7:08]And speaking of those researchers, the FFO report actually quotes Kate Harbath. Oh right. Who's a former Facebook executive. Yep. And she's become a pretty prominent figure in this whole censorship industry. She has. What does she have to say?
[7:22]Well she basically admitted that European laws like the DSA could help censors regain access to social media data that they've lost. So it sounds like they're trying to work around the pushback that they've been getting in the US. Right. By using the EU as leverage.
[7:37]It's a pretty clever strategy honestly. It is. They're leveraging international pressure to achieve something that they haven't been able to do at home. It's a perfect example of how those regulations in one part of the world can have these unintended consequences in another.
[7:51]So let's connect this back to our listeners here in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena. Sure. Why should they care about all of this? How could it impact their lives? Well for starters it could actually limit the information that they're able to access online.
[8:02]Even information that's like legal and relevant to their lives. Yeah potentially. The more power these censorship minded organizations have the greater the risk that valuable information is gonna get caught in their net. Right. You know you might be trying to research something that's really important to you.
[8:18]And suddenly it's gone. Wow. And it's not just about access to information. It's also about that chilling effect on free speech. Right. You know people are a lot less likely to speak their minds freely if they know they're being watched. Sure.
[8:31]And their words could be flagged as misinformation. It creates this environment where people are afraid to speak up. Exactly and that kind of environment really stifles open debate. Yeah. And the free exchange of ideas it's like being in a library where you're only allowed to read certain books.
[8:46]And then there's also this whole blurring of lines between government and private entities. Oh yeah that's a big one. These private organizations they're essentially doing the government's bidding. So when you have these government funded groups influencing what content gets removed from like Facebook or YouTube it raises some serious questions about who's really in control.
[9:05]Absolutely it's like this shadow censorship system. It's operating outside those normal checks and balances that we expect. In a democracy. Exactly it's not transparent and it's certainly not accountable to the people. And that's a slippery slope.
[9:18]Oh it is a slippery slope and it's one that we need to be really careful about. You know the future of online speech is at stake here and it's really up to all of us to be informed and to be engaged in this debate. Right. We need to be asking those tough questions.
[9:30]Who's controlling the information we see online and what are their motives? It's easy to feel powerless when you're up against these huge global trends but you know our voices still matter. They really do. The more we talk about these issues the more awareness we raise.
[9:44]For sure. And the harder it is for these censorship efforts to operate in the shadows. Exactly change starts locally. If we want to protect free speech online we need to start by having these conversations right here in our communities. Right.
[9:56]With our friends, our neighbors. You know we need to educate ourselves and each other about the threats to online freedom
Part 3 · 10:01
[10:01]and we need to hold our elected officials accountable. That's what the deep dive is all about. That's right. Empowering our listeners to think critically and act locally. What's happening in Europe might seem distant. Yeah. But as we've discussed today it has the potential to impact all of us.
[10:17]So stay tuned for the final part of our deep dive where we'll leave you with some food for thought. So welcome back to the deep dive. We've been talking about you know how those American tax dollars are being used to fund these organizations that are involved in online censorship over in Europe.
[10:31]And how that could have a real impact right here at home. Right here in Southeast Houston. You know in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena. Exactly. It's fascinating because this isn't just some far off issue. Right. You know it could affect what you see and say online.
[10:45]Right here. Right in your own community. Yeah. Imagine trying to research something. Right. That's really important. Like local environmental issues. Yeah or like upcoming elections and suddenly. Poof has gone. Flagged is missing for man. Wow.
[10:58]That's a real possibility. It really is and it makes you think we trust these tech companies. Yeah. To connect us to information. Right. But who's really in control of what we see. That's the question. Yeah and are their interests even aligned with ours.
[11:12]I mean that's the big question isn't it. These big tech platforms they've become the modern day public square. They really have. And the potential for censorship you know that raises some serious concerns about freedom of speech and access to information.
[11:25]For sure and we've seen how quickly things can change online. Oh yeah. I think about how Elon Musk pushed back against those censorship demands in Brazil. He did. And Twitter. Now X. Now X ended up being banned in the entire country. That's power.
[11:39]It really is. So what can we do about it. I mean it feels like such a big complex issue. It is a complex issue but you know that doesn't mean we're powerless. Okay. We can start by being aware of what's happening. Right. Check out that full FFR report.
[11:51]We'll link to it in our show notes. It's packed with so much more information than we could even cover today. Yeah definitely check that out and most importantly talk about it. Share this information with your friends, your family, your neighbors.
[12:01]Get people talking. Yeah let's get people thinking critically about what they're seeing online and who's controlling the narrative. Absolutely. The more we talk about these issues the harder it is for censorship to just happen in the shadows.
[12:13]Exactly. We need to be engaged. Right. And we need to hold our elected officials accountable for protecting our digital freedoms. Absolutely. Remember change starts locally. It does. What we do here in our communities can have a ripple effect.
[12:25]Absolutely. So stay curious, stay informed. Yeah. And most importantly stay engaged. Thanks for joining us on the deep dive. And if you find value in what we do and want to support our mission of empowering our local community here in Southeast Houston, please consider donating at thinkandactlocally.com forward slash donate.
[12:44]You'll find a link in our show notes. See you next time.
