Apr 25, 2025 · 22 min

Urban Growth, Finance, and the Shifting City Landscape

About this episode

This YouTube transcript captures a discussion on the financial and developmental trends impacting American cities. Whitney Alfonso, an expert in public finance, outlines common municipal revenue sources like property and sales taxes, alongside major expenditure areas such as personnel and infrastructure. Dennis Strait, an architect, argues that post-1950 suburban development, driven by automobile use, has created unsustainable infrastructure costs. The conversation explores the lifespan and maintenance challenges of this infrastructure and considers how new urban amenities and the COVID-19 pandemic are further influencing city finances and growth patterns.

Chapters

  1. Part 1 · 0:00
  2. Part 2 · 5:02
  3. Part 3 · 10:04
  4. Part 4 · 15:04
  5. Part 5 · 20:05

Transcript

Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.

Part 1 · 0:00

[0:00]Welcome to the deep dive today. We're going straight into something that well, it affects all of us living in American cities Especially right here in Deer Park La Porte and Pasadena. Absolutely We're talking about how our cities are financed and how these big development trends are really shaping our communities Yeah, and we've got a really insightful discussion to unpack It comes from a forum at the Dole Institute of politics and our guides for this are basically Excerpts from a video. We've got Whitney Alfonso She's an expert on state and local public finance from UNC Chapel Hill, right and Dennis Strait Who's an architect and landscape architect lots of experience in urban planning and what's really crucial here I think for listeners to grasp right off the bat is The financial engine, you know what keeps our cities actually running exactly the revenue streams the pressures They're under and where things might be heading especially for folks in southeast Houston Understanding these let's call them financial underpinnings it's key key to seeing the opportunities and frankly the challenges in your own neighborhoods and Figuring out how you can maybe get involved shape that future precisely Okay, so let's get into the nuts and bolts. How do cities actually make money?

[1:11]Whitney laid out the common sources, you know before the pandemic just turned everything upside down Yeah, the pre pandemic baseline. She said property taxes. That's traditionally been the big one, right? The main pillar historically. Yes That's been the most stable kind of foundational source for funding local services police fire schools roads Mostly funded that way, but it's interesting. She also mentioned sales tax is becoming more important Definitely a growing trend though It's worth noting not every city or county can levy a sales tax state laws vary quite a bit on that, right?

[1:45]So where they do have it it's a bigger piece of the pie now It is but it also introduces a different kind of dynamic sales tax revenue goes up and down with the economy with consumer spending It's less predictable than property tax makes sense and it's not just those two is it cities also get money from like Fines and fees. Oh, yeah parking tickets permits that sort of thing and in some places Occupancy taxes are significant. That's the hotel tax, right?

[2:11]Exactly tourists and business travelers contribute through that and then you have a few places like in Ohio or New York City that even have local income taxes Wow So it really is a mix kind of a patchwork depending on where you are It is and that mix really affects the city's financial health its resilience when you know, the economy takes a downturn We certainly saw that recently. Okay, so that's revenue. Where's the money going? What are the big spending categories?

[2:38]Well, Whitney pointed out some pretty consistent ones across the board. The biggest usually is personnel salaries benefits for city employees Yep, that tends to be the largest slice of the operating budget. No real surprise there. Okay, what else?

[2:51]Infrastructure is huge, but that's often handled a bit differently more through capital budgets Think big projects road construction water main replacements stuff that costs a lot up front Exactly, and then pensions for retired public workers. That's another substantial and often growing expense Yeah You hear a lot about pension liabilities and of course public safety police and fire departments always a major cost center But it feels like cities are being asked to do more now than just you know, the basics That's a really critical point something Dennis straight emphasized too. It's not just about filling potholes and collecting trash anymore There's this growing expectation especially relevant for places like Deer Park La Porte Pasadena for cities to invest in things like affordable housing living wage policies equity initiatives Greenways bike paths better public transportation It's a much broader mandate than it used to be and all those things cost money adding pressure to the budget Absolutely, which ties into this really Thought provoking idea from Dennis straight. He basically challenges the whole way We've built cities since the 1950s the suburban growth model driven by cars. Exactly. He argues. It's not just a different lifestyle It's a fundamentally new and potentially unsustainable way of organizing ourselves. How so what's the core problem?

[4:10]Well, think about how cities worked for centuries people had to live relatively close together close to shops jobs amenities Proximity was key because you walked or maybe had a horse or a streetcar, right? Then comes the widespread adoption of the automobile Suddenly distance isn't the same barrier you can live further out and that leads to sprawl the kind of landscape many of us Live in now right in southeast Houston and elsewhere precisely But straight says this shift has created some serious long-term financial headaches. Okay, explain that what are the headaches?

[4:44]It comes down to infrastructure lifespans He uses streets as an example. Maybe they last about 50 years give or take. Okay. Well think about it a huge amount of that post 1950 suburban infrastructure the roads the pipes everything is now hitting that 50 60 70 year mark

Part 2 · 5:02

[5:02]So it's all starting to wear out around the same time you got it Which means communities including many around Houston are facing this massive wave of necessary and very expensive Reinvestment and here's the kicker I assume the kicker is straight argues this low density Spread out model requires way more infrastructure per person or per house More miles of roads pipes wires compared to a more compact city, right?

[5:29]But it doesn't generate enough tax revenue particularly property tax revenue from that spread out land To actually pay for the long-term maintenance and replacement of all that infrastructure So it's like digging a financial hole That's exactly how he describes it a growing financial hole and you see the effects don't you the condition of local roads?

[5:48]Maybe water main breaks. That's often the visible result Yeah, you definitely notice aging infrastructure and Whitney Alfonso added another layer here She talked about the 1970s which saw not just more reliance on sales taxes But also the rise of tax and expenditure limits caps on how much cities could tax or spend essentially Yeah, so while revenue tools were changing sometimes being restricted the demands on cities the responsibilities were actually increasing like we just talked about So more responsibilities sometimes tighter revenue constraints and aging infrastructure from sprawl. That's a tough combination It's a perfect storm Financially speaking for many places this leads right into that idea of the urban core versus the suburbs Dennis straights point is that traditionally the dense city center was the economic engine, right?

[6:35]Yeah, historically that's where the highest concentration of economic activity was businesses jobs Generating more tax revenue per square foot or per acre than lower density areas Makes sense more value packed into a smaller space and straight argues that the current balance Vast amounts of this less revenue productive suburban land compared to the relatively smaller highly productive urban core is Kind of historically weird. It's out of whack. This type of sprawl is a pretty recent invention in the grand scheme of city-building Relatively speaking. Yes, and his key assertion Which is pretty provocative is is that suburban living because of those high infrastructure demands is often implicitly subsidized Subsidized how because the property taxes generated in many low-density suburbs often don't actually cover the full long-term cost of Providing and maintaining the roads water sewer schools everything needed out there So the denser parts of the region or maybe state and federal funds are indirectly picking up the slack That's the implication of his analysis The math often doesn't add up locally and he pointed out that even supposedly wealthy suburbs aren't immune They can get hit hard when growth slows down, right?

[7:46]He mentioned the downturn about a decade ago when development stalled even affluent suburbs Suddenly had to make cuts to public services because that continuous growth model is fragile It relies on constantly expanding constantly building when that music stops the underlying financial strains become really clear Okay, let's talk about those new demands on cities Whitney mentioned things like bike lanes greenways Yeah, these newer amenities that people increasingly want which is great It reflects changing values desire for recreation sustainability But it adds another layer of cost onto the traditional stuff roads water power It absolutely does cities are expected to maintain the old and build the new and done a straight had that interesting point about why We need separate bike lanes so often. Oh, yeah the street design issue Because we design so many streets primarily almost exclusively for cars. They're just not safe for walking or biking exactly So now we have to come back and build separate infrastructure like dedicated bike lanes or side paths to make it safe for other users Yeah, it's like compensating for past design choices. Whereas older streets may be handled different modes more naturally often Yes before the car completely dominated planning streets were more multifunctional by necessity He also connected sprawl to affordable housing challenges. How did that work through zoning?

[9:05]He argued that modern zoning practices which often rigidly separate land uses residential here commercial there Single-family homes only in this zone. That's a relatively new thing compared to historical patterns. Yes older neighborhoods He said often had a much greater mix apartments above shops different house sizes on the same block a wider range of price points Integrated together and modern zoning prevents that mix it often does By mandating large lots or prohibiting multifamily housing in certain areas it effectively limits the supply of smaller Potentially more affordable housing options. It creates less diversity. Okay, that makes sense. This brings us to density and downtown revitalization Lots of cities try to boost their downtowns right increased density there. Yeah, it's a common strategy Thinkers like Richard Florida popularized the idea that a vibrant dense downtown acts as an economic catalyst We heard the Kansas City example their downtown population grew and it seemed to help the city's economy overall

Part 3 · 10:04

[10:04]The logic is sound on the surface Concentrate activity attract businesses generate more tax revenue efficiently from that core area make better use of existing infrastructure, too But there was a question raised wasn't there about the cost versus the benefit? Yes That's the critical question these downtown revitalization efforts often involve significant public investment tax incentives for developers Infrastructure upgrades new parks, maybe a streetcar does that investment always pay off for the city's general fund Does the increased activity generate enough new revenue to justify the cost? It's not always clear. It requires really careful analysis While a buzzing downtown looks great. You have to ask if it's truly strengthening the city's overall financial position or Mainly benefiting specific developers or downtown residents and there's that churn to Whitney mentioned Younger people might move downtown right for the lifestyle of the excitement But then they start families and often move out to the suburbs Meaning cities constantly need to attract new waves of young professionals or maybe empty nesters to keep that downtown Vibrancy going it's an ongoing effort. That's not necessarily a one-time fix. Definitely not it requires sustained effort and investment This all comes back to how cities compete Whitney mentioned the cost of living issue It's often just more expensive inside the city limits right housing taxes Yeah, that's a major factor people compare housing costs property taxes Maybe school quality and the suburbs often look more appealing on a spreadsheet at least initially Even if as straight argues the long-term costs of suburban infrastructure aren't fully factored in by the homeowner Exactly perception versus long-term reality and she brought up the property tax issue again People commute in use city services wear out city roads, but if they live outside the city They aren't paying city property taxes So they benefit from the services without contributing through that main revenue source that free rider Problem essentially which is why cities often look to things like sales taxes or occupancy taxes Yeah, those do capture revenue from non-residents from commuters buying lunch or tourists staying in hotels But those can be politically difficult to implement or raise as Whitney noted Very much. So especially if surrounding jurisdictions don't see a direct benefit to themselves like that failed transportation sales tax in Atlanta She mentioned getting regional cooperation on funding is tough extremely tough Everyone wants the benefits of regional infrastructure, but agreeing on who pays and how much that's a huge political challenge Differing priorities local politics. It often stalls regional solutions. Okay, let's shift slightly to how cities spend Whitney explained the difference between operating budgets and capital budgets right operating is the day-to-day stuff salaries pensions supplies Utilities usually funded by current revenues like taxes and fees and capital is the big long-term stuff infrastructure exactly roads Buildings major equipment. Those are typically funded through borrowing issuing bonds taking on debt separate pot of money managed differently Understanding that split is important. They aren't just dipping into the same bucket for salaries and road paving generally not No, though Sometimes financial stress can blur those lines or lead to under investment in capital projects to protect the operating budget and she also flagged Those pension obligations again big sometimes underfunded liabilities. Yes That's a major shadow hanging over many city budgets promises made years ago that require significant funding today and tomorrow If those aren't managed well, they can crowd out funding for other services There was also a suggestion maybe related to personnel costs that older Larger cities might just be less efficient than newer suburbs. The idea was floated Yeah, that perhaps older cities have accumulated more layers of administration more legacy costs higher personnel expenses per capita compared to Leaner newer suburban governments. Is that fair? Do you think it's complex older cities often provide a wider range of services Deal with more complex social issues and have older infrastructure needing more maintenance But it's certainly an area where efficiency is always being scrutinized Dennis straight tied this back to the age thing older cities like Kansas City might just have been following these Less sustainable sprawl patterns for longer, right?

[14:23]So they might have deeper infrastructure deficits more entrenched financial habits that are Harder to change compared to a suburb built mostly in the last 30 years history matters and that history dramatically affects public transit, too Dennis's point about old Kansas City fascinating comparison pre 1950s much denser population packed into a smaller area and an extensive private streetcar system serving that dense Population exactly density makes transit viable even profitable potentially Lots of people close together means lots of potential riders for every mile of track or bus route Contrast that with today Kansas City, Missouri The city itself has a much lower population density, even though it's land area ballooned outwards

Part 4 · 15:04

[15:04]yeah, the population spread way out and That makes providing good frequent affordable public transit Incredibly challenging why just the distance is involved distances Yes, but also the low number of people living or working near any given stop You need massive scale huge subsidies to make traditional transit work. Well in a very low density environment It's just geometry and economics. So those modern transit projects like the KC streetcar we mentioned often They're focused on revitalizing a specific corridor usually the downtown or a dense node They can be great for that area But they don't necessarily solve the transportation problem for the majority of people living in the wider sprawling region That's often the critique and then you get into questions about who benefits most and who pays is It's serving essential commuting needs or is it more about tourism and downtown development subsidized by all taxpayers Right that free ridership question again in a different context Tough questions about priorities and effectiveness. Okay, we absolutely have to talk about kovat 19 Whitney described the impact on city finances as unprecedented uncertainty totally unprecedented Cities make budgets based on forecasts predictions of revenue suddenly Bam the economy slammed shut all those forecasts were just out the window a massive shock to the system huge and Immediate she noted property taxes held up. Okay, relatively speaking. They're less volatile Yeah property assessments don't change overnight, but other key revenues fail taxes occupancy taxes plummeted Especially early on think about restaurants shops hotels closing or having drastically reduced business Utility revenue sometimes dropped too as businesses closed and she saw a difference in the recovery speed right between big cities and smaller places Yeah, that was interesting rural and mid-sized cities their sale tax often bounced back quicker Maybe because people were staying local shopping local. Where is the big urban centers? They suffered longer Why because they rely so much more on business travel on daily commuters coming downtown on tourism All of that just cratered and took much longer to recover make sense So how did cities cope with these huge sudden shortfalls first stop usually is reserve funds Those rainy day funds cities are supposed to keep tapping into savings exactly, but those only last so long Then came the cuts hiring freezes were common furloughs for existing staff pausing capital projects infrastructure work delaying the inevitable in some cases pretty much and Lurking behind all this was the worry about long-term changes will remote work become permanent for a large chunk of the workforce What does that mean for downtown office buildings for restaurants that relied on office workers for transit systems big big questions It could fundamentally alter how cities function and how they're financed if those patterns shift permanently. So looking ahead What's the future hold?

[17:58]Whitney suggested cities might need a serious rethink. Yeah rethink how urban space is used Especially if business travel and daily commuting patterns really do change for good She saw a potential opportunity to write for more affordable cities Possibly if remote work takes hold Maybe people will choose to live in smaller or mid-sized cities that offer a good quality of life and amenities But without the super high costs of the biggest metro areas and Dennis saw the pandemic as a wake-up call a harsh one highlighting those financial vulnerabilities We've been talking about the fragility of the sprawl model and just reinforcing the need for more sustainable growth He mentioned self-driving cars briefly Disruptive, but maybe good in the long run. The impact is still really uncertain Could it reduce the need for parking make streets safer free of space currently dedicated to cars?

[18:49]Maybe could it encourage even more sprawl because commutes become less burdensome Also, maybe turi's still out on that one very much So but he did hold up Europe is a bit of a model because they never went quite as all-in on cars Exactly many European cities retain more density more mixed-use development and invested more consistently in walking cycling and public transit Infrastructure their streets are often designed for multiple modes. Not just the car lessons. We could learn here. Definitely creating more human centered Multimodal and ultimately more sustainable urban environments. The pandemic might actually push us faster in that direction But the recovery itself financially will take time. Oh, yeah, both Whitney and Dennis agreed on that It's likely a multi-year process for city finances to fully recover requiring really careful management and smart planning Okay, so wrapping this all up this deep dive really showed us I think the foundations of city finance that historical reliance on property tax the growing role and volatility of sales tax and the huge impact of that post World War two Suburban development pattern the infrastructure burden it created right and layered on top of that all the new things cities are expected To do now affordable housing greenways transit equity while dealing with legacy costs like pensions

Part 5 · 20:05

[20:05]And then of course the massive ongoing disruption from kovat 19 It's a complex picture and for our listeners in Deer Park La Porte and Pasadena understanding these big trends really gives context doesn't it for local debates about a new development or road funding or what services the City should prioritize Absolutely, it helps you see how your local situation fits into these larger national patterns and challenges It prompts you to ask how are these dynamics playing out right here?

[20:32]It certainly raises important questions about the long-term sustainability and vibrancy of our own communities It really does and on that note. Here's a final thought especially for everyone listening in southeast Houston. Yeah Given all these pressures the financial constraints the changing needs what kind of innovative may be creative Forward-thinking approaches could residents in Deer Park La Porte Pasadena explore Yeah, what can be done locally to ensure your communities remain vital and sustainable for the long haul Maybe it involves getting more engaged in local planning Thinking critically about the type of development that truly serves the community and the region's future. That's a powerful call to action Local engagement really can shape the future Well, this has been a deep dive into municipal finance and urban development If you found this valuable if you want to support more discussions like this that aim to empower you the residents to understand And act on local issues right here. Please consider supporting the work You can visit think and act locally comm forward slash donate. We'll put that link in the show notes. Thanks for tuning in

Related