Subsidies and City Economic Development: A Critical Discussion
About this episode
This YouTube transcript captures a Dole Institute of Politics discussion on economic development incentives, or subsidies, used by cities. The host and guests, all critical of these practices, define subsidies as government provisions lowering business costs for specific entities. They trace the history of subsidies back to the Great Depression and discuss their evolution, including the emergence of clawbacks and the “border wars” between neighboring jurisdictions. The conversation further examines the ineffectiveness of many subsidies, particularly for convention centers, highlighting inflated economic impact projections and the influence of consultants. Ultimately, the speakers question the value and opportunity costs of these incentives, suggesting alternative approaches like focusing on the quality of place.
Chapters
Transcript
Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.
Part 1 · 0:00
[0:00]Welcome to the deep dive, you know here in southeast, Houston for folks in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena This topic economic development incentives. Well, it pops up quite a bit. It really does So today we're digging into what these things sometimes called subsidies actually are we've looked at some research experts like Michael LaFave Heywood Sanders and there's there's a lot here. Definitely. So you hear about tax credits abatements subsidies What's the basic idea? Okay, so simply put their benefits provided by government could be local state federal level, right?
[0:36]And they're designed to make it cheaper Maybe more profitable for you know specific businesses or whole industries to set up shop or stay put like a special deal from the government exactly a special deal to Attract or keep certain kinds of economic activity. Gotcha and I hear incentives I hear subsidies are they pretty much the same thing or is there a difference?
[0:57]You know know about for the most part. Yeah, you can think of them as interchangeable their goals the same giving one company or industry a leg up a competitive advantage Some people might get technical say a subsidy is more like direct cash while an incentive might be a tax break may be easing up on rules, but Honestly, the core idea it's the same right, right? So it's not just like cash handouts. We're talking tools like Tax increment financing is that one? That's a big one. Yeah tiff they call it using future tax money to pay for today's costs and Enhanced enterprise zones those offer tax advantages to exactly They're all just different ways governments try to give certain businesses a boost different tools in the toolbox You know make sense and like one expert we read pointed out even something like say Michigan funding tourism ads. Oh, yeah. Yeah taxpayer money there It shares that same basic idea using public funds to help out a specific sector. Hmm interesting So it's not like this is some new invention then this has been around. Oh, not at all I mean different forms have existed for ages But the modern version the kind we see a lot today that really got its start back in the Great Depression No kidding. We're down in Mississippi two towns Columbia and Durant. They were kind of pioneers. What did they do?
[2:14]Well, their first idea was pretty clever actually private citizens local folks they put up their own property as collateral Wow Yeah to build factory buildings. The whole point was to attract manufacturers get them to move there and create jobs Offering them a building was the incentive. So it started really local private initiative How did it become the you know, the big public programs we see everywhere now Well the mayor of Columbia back then he later became governor of Mississippi And he liked the idea wanted to take it statewide. So that led to what's generally seen as the first Industrial revenue bond program basically cities could issue bonds public tech. Yeah public debt to Finance buildings or equipment for businesses using public money as the incentive and Durant you mentioned Durant, right?
[3:02]Durant's got a special place in this story It was the first city where a company actually moved across state lines because of incentives a hosiery company came down from Indianapolis So that was the beginning of the the border wars kind of you could say that yeah, it's at the stage and now Industrial revenue bonds are everywhere super common, but they trace back to Mississippi in the depression. That's fascinating history So once it kicked off had people always thought these incentives were a good idea Oh, definitely not attitudes have gone back and forth really over the last say 25 years or so You've seen cycles federal state local levels all over the place like what well back in the 1990s There was actually a pretty big pushback people were calling for Congress to ban them States were talking about making deals like compacts to stop poaching each other's businesses with subsidies So trying to call a truce in the border war exactly. There was real worry. It was just destructive competition So what happened did they stop? Not really what we saw instead were these Technocratic responses as one expert called them trying to make the deals look more accountable Technocratic. Yeah, things like putting clawback clauses in the deals, you know If the company doesn't create the jobs, they promised they have to pay the money back. Okay, that sounds reasonable Yeah, and things like getting executives to sign affidavit saying yes This incentive was the reason we came here trying to prove it was necessary the but for cause right but for this Incentive precisely and also sometimes local votes Referendums, especially for a really big visible stuff like sports stadiums San Francisco voters, for example They shot down public money for stadiums several times big projects get more attention I guess they really do but then you know things shifted again in the 2000s incentive use actually ramped up again. Oh boy Hard to say exactly. Maybe the pressure just built back up It wasn't really until after the Great Recession hit around 2008 2009 that some states
Part 2 · 5:02
[5:02]Michigan included started trying to pull back again. Maybe the financial reality hit home What about those clawbacks though? Did they actually work make companies pay back if they didn't deliver? Well, the experience there is Mixed maybe at first companies were a bit more careful But what happened over time in places like Missouri, Texas, Michigan Yeah, companies often just went back and renegotiated the deal if they weren't meeting targets avoided triggering the clawback So they're kind of paper tigers often. Yeah, there was sometimes this attitude of well It's a small loss among friends. Let's not make a big fuss. So the intention was good. Maybe But the follow-through wasn't always there. It feels like there must be really strong reasons to keep offering these things Why do so many local governments maybe even thinking about Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena here feel they have to offer them Oh, the pressures are huge Political pressure managerial pressure get this something like 95% of local governments offer some kind of incentive 95% Wow Yeah officials often feel like they have to maybe just to look good, you know announced jobs announced development positive PR Sometimes state law even pushes them into it that whole Amazon HQ 2 circus really showed that pressure didn't it?
[6:16]Yeah, absolutely. Remember that cities were falling all over themselves offering billions even cities that Realistically stood no chance. They felt they had to play the game or they look like they weren't even trying to be competitive Interestingly Toronto kind of bucked the trend. They basically said nope zero incentives Maybe they saw it as a race to the bottom good for them Yeah, and some smaller cities they were smart They put in a bid got some free PR but probably knew they weren't really in the running It makes you wonder though if you have to offer special deals Doesn't that kind of admit your regular taxes or regulations are maybe too high or too burdensome?
[6:55]Is that the conservative argument? That's definitely an argument you hear Yeah, if you need sweeteners, maybe the main course isn't appealing enough. It makes logical sense But is that how it plays out not always or at least it's not always discussed that way publicly often It just turns into this sort of mercantilist thing You know a border war driven more by headlines and PR than maybe sound economic policy Less about fixing fundamentals more about winning the next deal. So appearance over substance sometimes It can seem that way and the research it kind of backs that up Studies have found that areas with higher taxes. They tend to abate more offer more incentives okay, while areas with lower taxes tend to abate less and Historically those lower tax lower abatement places have often done better economically overall. Hmm So if your basic business climate is good You maybe don't need the extra deals as much that seems to be the pattern. Yeah, let's talk more about that border war Oh, yeah, Kansas City gets mentioned a lot right with the state line cutting through. Oh, it's the classic example Kansas versus Missouri right there. They've spent hundreds of millions literally over the years doing what trying to lure companies back and forth Across the state line Applebee's moved AMC theaters moved Waddell and read Big names shuffling a few miles for better deal. But does that actually create new jobs for the whole region or just move them around?
[8:19]That's the million dollar question, isn't it? Often the net gain for the region is minimal maybe even zero It just shifts activity highlights how incentives can just churn jobs locally instead of bringing in real growth from outside It sounds like companies have gotten really good at playing this game. Oh, absolutely They understand incentive shopping inside and out. It's strategic how so well a lot of times a company figures out where it wants To be first for solid business reasons workforce logistics market access, whatever right and then they go looking for incentives It's like the icing on the cake either proof of that. Yeah, there's documentation groups like good jobs first track the stuff There have been reports out of North Carolina Institutions showing this pattern Wow, there was even this infamous internal PowerPoint that got leaked from a major accounting firm the title was supposedly something like milking the cow milking the cow Seriously, who's the cow state government? It was basically a playbook on how to maximize the subsidies you could get that's pretty blatant Tells you something doesn't it and another thing a major corporation actually listed the potential loss of government Incentives as a risk factor to their profits in their official SEC filings So it's baked into their business model for some it seems like it which really underscores How important these subsidies can become not just for location decisions, but for ongoing profitability It does make you wonder if it distorts things like does it lead to bad decisions?
[9:49]It certainly can there was an interesting anecdote from Kansas City a hotel chain was offered Incentives to build but they actually turned them down. Why they said they felt the market was already saturated too many hotels
Part 3 · 10:02
[10:02]Which suggests, you know, maybe the incentives were encouraging more hotel building than the actual market demand warranted So you get a glut of certain things just because the subsidy makes it look profitable on paper Exactly. It points to a potential lack of sort of long-term planning, which seems like a big issue instead of Our communities Deer Park La Porte, Pasadena Having a clear strategy for what kind of development we need. Yeah, it becomes just Reacting to whoever shows up asking for a subsidy that happens way too often Unfortunately cities end up responding proposal by proposal developer by developer without maybe stepping back and asking Does this fit our long-term vision, right?
[10:43]It's different from say how Detroit approached things back in the 60s Their focus was much broader big infrastructure investments as the core strategy not just one-off deals This is a real challenge for us as residents then isn't it because we see a new building a ribbon-cutting. Yeah, it looks like success How do we see the other side of the coin? That's the core difficulty. Absolutely. The building is tangible You can see it touch it. What's harder to see is what didn't happen because the money went there the opportunity cost exactly That's the key concept What else could that public money our money here in southeast Houston have paid for fixing potholes better schools More police or fire protection. Yeah, there's a group the Center for Economic Accountability John Mazzina's work there They try to actually put numbers on those opportunity costs. Does that resonate with people?
[11:31]Yeah, the opportunity cost argument research suggests it does maybe more than just hearing the huge dollar figure of the incentive itself Voters especially independent voters seem to react more strongly when you talk about the potential loss of public services They rely on so less they spent 10 million dollars and more that 10 million dollars could have fixed X miles of road Kinda yeah, or look at Kansas City again You have these hugely successful locally grown companies like Burns and McDonnell Edon Cerner Cerner might be the biggest subsidy recipient there. Okay, and the argument gets made Were there new headquarters built in part at the expense of say funding for public school kids in the area It forces a tougher conversation. It's harder when the trade-off isn't so direct though It is and of course the people and companies benefiting directly from the deal They have a strong self-interest in promoting the upside and downplaying any costs. Let's pivot a bit convention centers That's a specific area where you see a ton of public money and subsidies, right?
[12:32]This could definitely affect us with Houston having major facilities nearby Oh, yeah convention centers are a whole fascinating case study within this larger topic. Where did that start publicly funded convention centers? Well public assembly buildings aren't new Think about memorials after World War one like in Kansas City and st. Louis back in the 20s and 30s big public halls Okay, but the big boom the modern convention center race that really kicked off in 1960 Chicago McCormick place that was kind of the first Huge purpose-built convention venue in the country and everyone else felt they had to keep up pretty much You literally had memos circulating between mayor's offices. Chicago's got this giant new thing We're falling behind it became part of urban renewal trying to revitalize downtown What was the rationale why pour public money into these huge buildings?
[13:22]The core argument then and now is attracting out-of-town visitors convention ears They come they spend money in hotels restaurants shops It's supposed to be a big injection of outside cash boosting the local economy But isn't it kind of weird cities spend millions billions building these centers But they also seem to assume the private market will just naturally build lots of hotels nearby. That is a peculiar disconnect Isn't it you constantly hear about the economic impact? That's the justification Do these places make money on their own just operating almost never if you look at just the operating budget Ignoring the massive construction cost nearly every publicly owned convention center runs at a loss. How do they justify it?
[14:06]It always comes back to that visitor spending argument The idea is the overall economic benefit to the city outweighs the centers operating loss and they often fund it with taxes That hit tourists hardest hotel taxes rental car taxes, maybe restaurant taxes So they can say locals aren't paying for this exactly. That's a very common narrative It's funded by the visitors into tracks, but those economic impact studies. Mm-hmm. You hear criticisms about those, too Oh, absolutely and for very good reasons. The standard method they use is often flawed How so typically they compare the economic activity with the convention happening to a baseline of basically zero Like if convention wasn't there the city would be a ghost town that weekend, which isn't realistic Not at all. Even without a big convention Hotels would have some guests right restaurants would be open people would be doing something
Part 4 · 15:00
[15:00]The studies rarely account for that baseline activity. They only count the new spending and they often ignore Displacement displacement. Yeah, like maybe locals avoid downtown when a huge convention is in town because it's crowded or prices go up That can cancel out some of the supposed gains They usually just report the big gross numbers not the realistic net impact So if the centers themselves lose money and the impact studies are maybe Optimistic. Mm-hmm who really benefits from building them? Well several players politicians definitely like them They're big shiny projects great for ribbon cuttings showing progress developers, obviously Big construction contracts lots of related development potentially make sense. And then there's a crucial group Convention Center consultant consultants. Yeah, these firms specialize in producing these glossy reports They compare your city to others usually find your liking behind and surprise Recommend building a bigger newer better facility and their reports always show it'll be a huge success They tend to come with very rosy projections for attendance hotel nights booked Economic impact again, usually gross figures not net. Can you give an example? Are those projections accurate? They're often wildly optimistic There's a famous example from Boston in 1997 The consultants predicted their new center would bring in 350,000 to 400,000 new annual attendees Wow and generate 789,000 new hotel room nights per year the actual number in 2019 a pretty good year before kovat 389,000 room nights less than half. Yeah, that kind of overestimation is pretty typical a good rule of thumb Take the consultants forecast and maybe cut it in half or even by two-thirds to get closer to reality So has any city figured out how to do tourism or conventions successfully without constantly chasing bigger subsidies and bigger buildings?
[16:50]That's tough Las Vegas always comes up right this seems successful. Yeah, but even Vegas They doubled the size of their main Convention Center in the early 2000s did attendance double No, it peeped before the 2008 recession at about 1.7 million attendees in 2019 It was down to 1.2 million so bigger didn't necessarily mean better even there right and there's a strong argument that the whole Convention industry was maybe flattening or even declining before 2020 hit more cities building bigger centers Chasing a market that wasn't really growing much meaning more competition for the same piece of pie Exactly, which leads to intense competition many major centers were doing less business in 2018 or 2019 than they did back in 2006 or 2007 Despite getting bigger. So what happens then you get a price war center start cutting deals Sometimes giving the space away for practically nothing just to get some activity in the building like that story about McDonald's Yeah, the Orlando Sentinel reported on it. McDonald's was having a big franchisee conference The rent was supposed to be something like one point six five million dollars The final bill zero they waived the whole thing Wow just to get them there just to get the hotel room nights and maybe some good PR So if the subsidy arms race isn't the best path Mm-hmm. What are the alternatives what could leaders here in Deer Park La Porte, Pasadena?
[18:11]Think about instead the conversation is shifting slowly Maybe but it's shifting more towards focusing on quality of place quality of place meaning meaning the fundamental things that make a community a good place to live and work good schools safe streets parks culture reliable infrastructure and Critically a skilled workforce and good workforce development programs sort of tinned your own garden first exactly Sometimes it's called sticking to the knitting or setting the table create a fundamentally strong attractive community And maybe businesses will want to come without needing a special deal a fair field and no favors kind of approach That's the idea. Maybe that's more sustainable long-term than constantly trying to buy jobs Are any places actually trying this?
[18:53]Moving away from incentives. We're seeing some signs Austin Texas has been getting maybe a bit stingier with big incentive packages lately Tesla famously didn't ask for state incentives for their factory there Oh interesting though the real test for Austin might be coming up with Samsung. They're considering a huge investment We'll see how that plays out anywhere else Memphis, Tennessee is another one to watch There's talk that they might put their main subsidy program on hiatus or maybe they already have that would be a really significant move If it happens, but for big cities, especially ones already deep in the convention game It's hard to find examples of success without subsidies and expansions, isn't it?
[19:37]It really is look at Austin again, even with their recent caution. They're still talking about a massive like 1.2 billion dollar Expansion of their convention center despite the trends We just discussed despite the trends Boston put a temporary pause on their expansion plan the while back because they weren't hitting the numbers They expected right but it's rare for a city to just say okay We're out of the scheme completely the political table as one expert said is just loaded with interests pushing for these projects
Part 5 · 20:04
[20:04]Vected interests. Yeah Local consultants who do the studies city councils who want to announce projects state economic development agencies Everyone's kind of on the same side of the table pushing for the deal sometimes even voters, you know They want to see something happening locally like that new hotel in Kansas City. You mentioned earlier the lows, right?
[20:24]Big shiny new hotel partly subsidized But now there are questions about whether there's enough business for it given the potential oversupply Maybe made worse by subsidies encouraging too much building and of course, nobody predicted a global pandemic hitting the travel industry Yeah, the impact of 2020 is still playing out. Isn't it huge unknown factor for all kinds of development?
[20:45]Okay, so bring it back home If our local city councils in Deer Park Laporte or Pasadena are looking at one of these deals a subsidy for a company maybe even something related to tourism or events What should they be watching out for? What are the red flags? The absolute number one thing has to be opportunity cost always ask What are we giving up to do this? What else could this money do for our community?
[21:10]Don't just look at the potential upside exactly and demand a realistic assessment of the net impact Not just the rosy gross numbers consultants often provide remember the consultant likely wants to get hired again They're kind of like expert witnesses paid to make the case So challenge their assumptions definitely demand analyses that include all the costs direct and indirect financial and opportunity costs Florida actually has an interesting model where they try to compare the impact of giving an incentive Versus investing that same money in a basket of public goods like education or infrastructure. That's smart. What else?
[21:45]Scrutinize the consultant ask about their track record show us where your past predictions actually came true Don't just take their word for it and specifically for those Convention Center or maybe hotel deals same thing But even more pointed ask the consultant. How accurate were your forecasts for city X Y & Z?
[22:03]Show us the actual performance data not just descriptions of how nice the building is demand real empirical evidence Got it and critically What is the downside risk if those projections don't happen and we've seen they often don't what's the financial hit who pays the price?
[22:19]What services get cut what happens if another 2020 event occurs cities owning hotels right now are facing huge challenges Understand the risk before you sign the check So due diligence on the consultants full cost accounting and understanding the real risk Absolutely, look closely at who you hire and make sure they count everything and always always check their past prediction accuracy That's really helpful. We had a listener asked specifically about a historical turning point We talked about Mississippi and the depression kicking off the business incentive competition Was there a similar moment for the Convention Center boom? That's a great question While McCormick place in 60 was a catalyst Maybe the bigger enabling factor for the explosion of Convention Centers Was the shift towards using revenue bonds tied to those visitor taxes the hotel tax rental car tax Why was that so important because in many places issuing revenue bonds doesn't require a direct vote of the public Like issuing general obligation bonds which pledge the city's full faith and credit often does so it bypasses the voters It often makes it politically easier Yeah It changed the game making it simpler to finance these massive projects without having to sell the public directly on taking on huge City debt you see it even today st Milwaukee recently issuing bonds for Convention projects without a direct public vote that really lowers the barrier doesn't it changes the political calculation entirely Fundament it makes you think Maybe our local leaders should be required to attend business closings to not just ribbon cuttings might give a more balanced view That's actually a really provocative thought. It certainly would provide a different perspective on the churn of economic activity, wouldn't it?
[24:00]Well, thank you for taking this this deep dive with us today Into this really complex world of economic development incentives and subsidies my pleasure. It's a lot to unpack It really is we've covered gosh the history the different types The big debate over whether they even work why opportunity cost is so crucial the specific issues with Convention centers the consultants Right and the need to really question the claims and check the track records So for everyone listening in Deer Park La Porte and Pasadena We hope this gives you some things to think about when you hear about potential local deals or new projects In our neck of the woods here in southeast Houston. Yeah, ask those tough questions What's the real cost not just the sticker price, but the opportunity cost?
[24:44]What else can we be doing with those resources and what's the actual history have similar projects worked elsewhere? We really dig into it and here's maybe a final thought to chew on Given everything we've discussed how can we as residents right here best push for economic growth?
Part 6 · 25:01
[25:01]That's truly sustainable and benefits everyone in our communities What should we be measuring besides just ribbon cuttings? What local numbers really tell the story? That's the key question for local action Remember think and act locally is all about empowering you the residents of Deer Park La Porte and Pasadena Texas with information you can use to make a difference right here If you found this discussion valuable, please consider supporting the show You can find out how at think and act locally comm forward slash donate that links also in the show notes
