Rick Cole on Strong Towns: Budgets, Morality, and Local Action
About this episode
This Strong Towns podcast episode features a conversation between Chuck Marone and Rick Cole, a seasoned public servant with experience as a mayor, city manager, and council member. They discuss Cole’s extensive background in local government, highlighting his early involvement in community leadership and his long career focused on municipal finance and urban development. Cole emphasizes the moral dimension of city budgets, viewing them as reflections of community values and priorities. The discussion explores the challenges of structural budget deficits, the need for data-driven decision-making rather than tradition or politics, and the importance of citizen engagement and understanding in effective self-governance. They touch on historical perspectives of essential services like fire departments and advocate for a shift towards a participatory model of local government where residents are partners in shaping their communities’ futures.
Chapters
Transcript
Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.
Part 1 · 0:00
[0:00]All right, hey there everybody out there in, you know, Deer Park, Laporte, Pasadena, welcome. You know, today we're gonna really kind of like, dig into something that I think is really, really important to all of us, especially those of us here in Southeast Houston, how we can all be part of making this, you know, a better place to live.
[0:20]Absolutely. And you know, I think like a good starting point for this is understanding that like, the decisions that are made about our local budgets, right, like our city councils. It's not just these like abstract numbers floating around.
[0:34]They really show what we value, what we prioritize as a community. Right. Yeah, it's often said that a budget is a moral document. Oh, that's a great way to put it. It really is. Yeah. And to dig into this more, we're gonna look at a really fascinating conversation with Rick Cole on the Strong Towns podcast.
[0:50]Right, Rick Cole, I mean, this guy's got experience, right? He does, yeah. Mayor, city manager, council member. Exactly. He brings, you know, that boots on the ground experience to this discussion. Yeah. And a deep understanding of how communities work, how they're funded.
[1:05]Yeah, so I mean, and that's kind of what, you know, our goal is today, right? Like taking his experience and kind of, you know, extracting these lessons that can empower, you know, you guys. Right. Our listeners in Deer Park, in Port Pasadena, to think and act locally.
[1:22]Right. Like to make a real difference right here where you live. Yeah, and Rick Cole, you know, he's been involved in this stuff since he was young, even. Yeah. You know, he shared an experience, you know, going back to his high school days.
[1:34]You know, Pasadena, his home hound, they were the first city west of the Mississippi to have court order desegregation. Wow. And, you know, he talked about how, you know, at that time, the adults didn't handle the situation that well. The students actually had to step up and lead.
[1:50]So, you know, it shows you that sometimes local change starts with individual initiative. Right. It's not always about waiting for the big solution from somewhere else. It's about seeing what needs to happen right here, right now. Right. And just doing it.
[2:04]And Rick, you know, he really emphasized this, this power of like, you know, focusing locally. He talked about the tangible impact you can have, you know, working with people, real people, you know, in your community and seeing those results like firsthand.
[2:19]Absolutely. And he talked about how important it is to actually have dialogue with people who have different viewpoints, especially in today's world. Yeah. You know, locally is where you have to engage with people who hold different opinions.
[2:29]Yeah. And he really values that ability to bridge those divides, which is why it's so fascinating that after a long career in city management, he's back on the Pasadena City Council now after like 29 years. Oh, wow. Which just shows you his commitment to local action.
[2:45]Yeah. That's a serious commitment. So let's dig a little bit deeper into this, this whole idea of budgets being like, these moral documents that Rick brought up. Like, they're not just about balancing the books. They really reflect what we hold dear, what we actually prioritize as a community.
[3:01]Exactly. And he uses a pretty basic phrase to highlight this. Yeah. You know, putting your money where your mouth is. Yeah. Essentially, the budget is where we, you know, actually make the decision about what's important and what's not. But, you know, he also pointed out that sometimes local governments can fall into this trap of just repeating the previous year's spending, maybe adding a little bit more, but not really questioning whether those spending choices still make sense.
[3:27]Right. It's easy to just keep doing what you've always done without really thinking about it. Exactly, yeah. And Rick brought up this concept of zero-based budgeting, which, you know, if you remember President Carter, that was kind of like, you know, a big part of his platform.
[3:41]But basically, like, the core idea is every budget cycle, you kind of start fresh, right? Right. Okay, if we were starting from scratch today, how would we allocate our resources to actually serve the community? Right, right. And, you know, talking about, you know, how we allocate resources, he shared this really interesting statistic about the Santa Monica Fire Department.
[4:03]They had, I think, over 15,000 emergency calls. Wow. Only 47 of those were for fires. Wow. 47 out of, what was it, like 15,000? Yeah, over 15,000 calls. That's incredible. It really makes you think, what are our emergency services actually spending their time and resources on?
[4:22]Yeah, exactly. Like, so most of those calls were for medical emergencies. But then there were also things like, you know, assisting elderly residents, responding to non-emergency situations at care facilities, you know, helping people with mobility issues.
[4:36]And it really raises the question, is it the most effective use? And, you know, going back to Rick's point about the moral aspect, is it really the most moral use of these highly trained firefighters and all this expensive equipment to handle these situations?
[4:49]Could those resources be better used in a different way, you know, to really meet the needs of the community? I mean, it makes you think, right? Like, these are incredibly skilled people with,
Part 2 · 5:00
[5:00]you know, we spend a lot of money on them, on their training, on their equipment. But, you know, are those resources being used in the best possible way to actually serve the needs of the people right here? Right. I mean, and that's a question that, you know, you should ask yourself.
[5:14]Right. Here in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena, have you ever actually, like, looked at your city budget and, like, thought about how that money is being divided up? Does it actually reflect, you know, what you see as, like, the biggest needs in your neighborhood?
[5:30]Good question to think about. Yeah, for sure. So, okay, now we kind of, we get into, like, some of the inherent difficulties in actually, you know, like, making changes, right? Like, in how local governments operate. And Rick pointed this out, like, we often see this pattern, right?
[5:44]Where it's like, oh, we've got this budget shortfall. Oh, no, we don't, we balance the budget. But, you know, sometimes it's not very clear how that magic happens, right? Yeah, exactly. And a lot of times, that balancing act happens because there's a structural imbalance, you know?
[5:57]Like, the costs of providing all these services are going up faster than the money that's coming in. Right. That's a tough problem to solve in the long term. I mean, think about it, like, if your household budget is like that, you know, like, your bills keep going up, but your income stays the same, you're gonna have a problem eventually.
[6:15]Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's unsustainable, right? And, you know, it's that fire department example, you know? It illustrates how hard it can be to, like, move resources away from these established ways of doing things, even when we have, you know, information showing that maybe there's a better way, a more affordable way to handle, you know, a lot of these calls that they get.
[6:36]Right. And Rick put it really well. He said, you know, if it was easy, more cities would do it. Exactly. Right, like, that really gets to the heart of, you know, how these systems work. Yeah. And Rick also stressed how important it is to actually use data to make these decisions.
[6:51]Right. You know, instead of relying on anecdotes or what's popular or just saying, well, this is how we've always done it. That's never a good answer, is it? That's how we've always done it. No. Not really. So what's a good example of, like, you know, this can really go wrong, right?
[7:09]Like, when you don't use data to make these decisions. Yeah, well, you know, he told a story about budget cuts in Oakland and how, when they had to make some really tough choices, what they considered essential wasn't based on any objective criteria.
[7:22]Oh, wow. It was based on which groups were the most organized and the loudest at city council meetings. So, like, recreation programs were protected because they had a lot of people advocating for them. Yeah. But things like bridges and streetlights were kind of neglected.
[7:36]Right. And what happened, you know, there was this streetlight that wasn't properly maintained and it fell and injured somebody. Yeah. And it cost the city $17 million. That's what happens when you make these kind of reactive, politically driven decisions.
[7:50]Yeah. That really shows you how that can really backfire in a huge way. So then, you know, Rick kind of introduced this way to think about how effective our spending is, right? Like, inputs, outputs, and then I think most importantly, outcomes.
[8:06]Exactly. And he explains that, you know, just putting more money into something, which is the input, doesn't automatically mean you're gonna get the result you want. You know, the outcome. Right. We need to look at the outputs. You know, what's actually being done.
[8:21]Right. But the real measure of success is are we actually getting the outcome that we're aiming for? Like, you know, if we double the budget for domestic violence prevention. Right. Doesn't necessarily mean that domestic violence is gonna go down.
[8:35]Yeah. We have to look at how that money is being used. Yeah. What activities are actually happening. Are they actually effective? You know? Going beyond just saying we spend the money, right? It's about, did it actually make a difference, you know, in people's lives?
[8:48]Right. And he connected this to, you know, they spend a lot of money in LA County on the homeless crisis. Right. Billions of dollars. And, you know, voters even approved higher taxes because they expected to see results, right? Right. But the results haven't really matched the level of investment.
[9:04]Yeah. And that raises some important questions about trust and accountability. You know, what are we actually doing with these tax dollars? We're actually using them effectively. Right. You know, and Rick talked about his experience in Mususa, where when he was city manager, his thing was like, we're gonna show results with what we have before we ask voters for more money.
[9:22]Right. It was all about building trust. You know? Being responsible with the money that they already had. Yeah. I mean, that makes sense. Show people that, that you can handle what you have, and then maybe they'll be more willing to, you know, give you more to work with.
[9:36]So, I mean, this all leads to, like, this really important role that citizens play in all this, right? Yeah. And Rick's perspective on, you know, I guess what he sees as a disconnect in this idea of self-government. Yeah. You know, he talked about this tension between people who wanna shrink the government and people who just want more funding for programs.
[9:58]Right. But, you know, he pointed out that,
Part 3 · 10:01
[10:01]you know, Strong Towns is about, you know, a different way. It's about making the government more effective. Right. More responsive. Yeah. And he kinda laid out some different structures of local government, right? Like the strong mayor versus city manager systems, just to kinda give everybody a sense of, you know, who's running things.
[10:20]Right. But, you know, his most thought-provoking idea, I think, is about what the core purpose of local government really should be. Yeah. And he argues that it's to make the city safe and prosperous. Right. Not just to run a bunch of departments, like police and fire, you know.
[10:34]Yeah. He admits that this might be a bit of a controversial viewpoint, but, you know. But it makes you think, right, like, it gets back to that, like, Simon Sinek, why? Yeah. You know. Right. Like, we often focus on what they do, how they do it.
[10:48]But we don't always think about, like, the fundamental reason. Oh, why? Yeah, exactly. Why do we even have this in the first place? Yeah. And to illustrate this, you know, he brought up a really fascinating point about the history of fire departments.
[11:04]Oh, yeah. And how they weren't always run by the government. I mean, you know, you used to have to pay for private fire companies. Oh, wow. And then there were these other groups that would, like, show up at a fire and demand payment to put it out.
[11:17]Oh, my God. I mean, it wasn't until, you know, the mid-1800s after, you know, this huge fire in Cincinnati, and somebody came up with a better fire engine. Right. That the idea of government-run fire departments took hold. And even then, people didn't really want the government involved.
[11:33]That's amazing. I mean, it's just, it's a good reminder that all this stuff that we just kind of, like, take for granted now, got its own evolution, you know? And Rick was really careful to say, you know, he's not trying to criticize firefighters.
[11:47]He's just trying to encourage us to, you know, to think creatively. About how we solve these problems today, you know? Yeah. And he made a similar point about policing. You know, we need to really think about how we respond to these different situations.
[12:02]You know, we can't just overload our officers with, you know, every little thing, from a minor argument to a bank robbery. Yeah. You know? Maybe there should be unarmed responders for certain things. Right. And it costs a lot of money to have these, you know, these highly trained and equipped officers for every single call.
[12:22]Right. And, you know, this ties in with the whole strong towns approach to streets, right? You know, like, we have to think about safety, balancing different transportation options. Not just about, you know, making sure cars can go as fast as possible.
[12:36]Right. You know? Yeah. So, I mean, ultimately, Rick pointed out that, like, you know, the core of making government work better is in budgeting. Right. And addressing, you know, how we've been neglecting our infrastructure for so long. Right.
[12:50]And this, you know, comes back to that quote by Napoleon. Yeah, about the trees, right? About planting trees. Yeah. You know, it's a long-term vision. Yeah. So, okay, so we hear a lot about these budget deficits, right? And Rick made a really good point.
[13:02]You know, he said, you know, you can't just blame, you know, whoever's in charge right now. Right. You know? A lot of this is because of long-term trends and how our finances are structured. Right. He had this great analogy. He said, you know, there's no royal road to geometry.
[13:18]Right. Meaning, you know, if we want to really understand our local government, if we want to really engage with it, it's gonna take some effort. Right. You know? We can't just sit back and expect our elected officials to just handle it all perfectly.
[13:30]We have to get involved. We have to, yeah. It's more than just voting, right? Yeah, it's more than just voting. And he made this really interesting comparison to a vending machine. Yeah, I like that one. Yeah. It's like, you know, we treat government like a vending machine, right?
[13:46]Right. We put our money in. We expect to get exactly what we want out. Yeah. And if we don't, we're upset, right? Yeah, and he contrasted that with the idea of a barn raising. Oh, yeah. You know? Like people coming together, you know, using their skills, contributing their effort.
[14:01]Yeah. And they have a stake in the outcome, you know? They own it, right. They own it, exactly. You're not gonna tear down a barn that you helped build. Yeah, exactly. Right, so I mean, that's a great image, right? Like neighbors working together to build something.
[14:15]Right. And he told the story about, there was this area in a park, right, that was kind of neglected and dangerous. Yeah. And the residents, you know, with a little bit of guidance and some resources, they just took care of themselves. Yeah.
[14:33]They cleaned it up. They made it better. And that's what builds that sense of, you know, pride of ownership. Exactly, and he makes a good point that, you know, real trust in government doesn't come from having, you know, these perfect leaders.
[14:46]It comes from us actually being involved and engaged. Right, you know? And he shared this story about, you know, when he was a new council member, he was asking all these, you know, tough questions. Yeah. And the city manager, you know,
Part 4 · 15:00
[15:00]instead of getting defensive, he took the time to actually teach him about municipal finance. Right. You know, and that gave him this much deeper understanding of how everything works. Yeah, that's awesome. So, and then he used that famous Willie Sutton quote.
[15:15]About banks. Yeah. That's where the money is. You know, to kind of make the point that, you know, the budget is where, like, the rubber meets the road. That's where the values are. Yeah, that's where you really see what matters to the people running the government.
[15:30]Absolutely. And, you know, we have to balance the budget, right? Yeah, legally. Yeah, it's not an option to just run a deficit forever. Right. So, and, you know, despite all the, you know, the craziness in national politics and everything, you know, what Rick found is that, like, at the local level, people are pretty reasonable, but, you know, a lot of times they just don't know how things work.
[15:53]And part of that's because of, you know, local news isn't what it used to be and these civic organizations that used to be so strong, you know, have kind of gone away in a lot of places. Right, yeah, and that's why, you know, what we're doing here is so important, you know, giving people the information they need to actually make a difference locally.
[16:11]Right, like empowering people. Right. And that's the Strong Towns model, right? Start by observing a problem in your neighborhood. Yeah. Take some action, you know? Take action, yeah. So now we get to, you know, the role of city employees and all this, you know?
[16:26]And Rick talked about how, you know, sometimes city professionals, you know, planners, engineers, all those folks, they can kind of get in this mindset where they think, okay, our job is just to manage these services for the taxpayers. Right, great.
[16:40]But, you know, it's a little bit deeper than that. You know, a lot of these professionals, they feel like their expertise is not valued and they get a lot of, you know, unrealistic input from the public. Yeah, and, you know, Rick told the story about when he was mayor and they had this general plan, you know?
[16:58]It was like 250 pages long, really complex document. Wow. And they had to put it to a public vote, which is not always the case. Right. But he used this analogy of a doctor and a patient, you know? Yeah. Like, you have to have informed consent.
[17:13]Right. And even if you're an expert, you have to engage with the public. Yeah. Offer them choices, build trust through communication. Because, you know, these days, everybody can just go on Google and, you know, do their own research, right?
[17:25]So you have to be able to talk to people. You have to meet them where they are. Yeah, absolutely. So, and he talked about, you know, the planners, they were really hesitant to engage with the community. Yeah, they were afraid of the same old stuff.
[17:37]Yeah. You know, like the same 30 people showing up, meetings going on forever, people yelling at them, you don't know what you're doing, you know? Right, you're the expert, so what happened? Well, they actually ended up creating a really great general plan.
[17:52]Okay. You know, it won an award. Wow. It got 58% voter approval. And it's still having a positive impact on Pasadena today. Wow, so it actually worked. It worked, yeah. And the key takeaway was that, you know, the chief planner went from feeling like this, you know, misunderstood expert, to actually being a valued resource.
[18:12]Right. You know, helping the community achieve what they wanted to achieve. Right, so it's a partnership, right? It's not just, you know, the expert telling everybody what to do. Right. Yeah. So, you know, Rick admitted that it's a lot harder to do this kind of, you know, really engaged self-government in a huge city like LA.
[18:32]Right. But he also pointed out that, like, you know, this top-down approach, where it's like, just stay home, we'll take care of it, hasn't really worked out that well either. It hasn't, you know? And he brought up this guy in LA, Kenneth Mejia, the city controller.
[18:47]And he's done a really good job of using social media and, you know, even humor to connect with people. Right. And he pushes transparency and accountability. And, you know, he had a really impressive victory. Yeah, he did. And got a bunch of volunteers involved.
[19:02]Right. So, I mean, it's possible, right? Check. To get people engaged. Yeah, even in a big city. Yeah, for sure. Okay, so we're kind of, we're coming towards the end here, and Rick went back to that Napoleon quote about, you know, planting trees.
[19:16]Right. And applied it to our infrastructure. Like, you know, we neglect maintenance to balance the budget in the short term. But the consequences of that, you know, play out over years and years. Right, and he argued that, you know, our problems aren't just about not spending enough on infrastructure.
[19:33]It's also about, you know, the way we're developing our cities. Like, these sprawling patterns are, they're not financially sustainable. Right. Yeah, so he talked about how his own, you know, journey led him to the Congress for the New Urbanism, because he was looking for better ways to, you know, develop our cities in a way that makes financial sense.
[19:56]Right. And he found that in these new urbanist principles. Yeah, which we've talked about before on the show.
Part 5 · 20:00
[20:00]Right. You know, so it was interesting to hear that, that that's what kind of led him down that path. Yeah, and he admitted that it's tough to change those patterns, even in a city like Pasadena. Right. Which is, you know, a pretty successful city.
[20:12]Yeah, it is. But they have a lot of single-family home neighborhoods. Right. You know, people don't always want change. Right, that's their investment. Right, exactly. Yeah, for sure. But, you know, he emphasized that the benefits, they might not be immediate.
[20:28]Right. But in the long run, you know, 20 years down the road. Right. You're gonna see a real difference. You're gonna see a difference, yeah. Yeah. So, and then he brought up this current challenge that they're dealing with in Pasadena right now, Washington Boulevard.
[20:42]Yeah. Like people are speeding like crazy on the street. It's like 84 miles an hour, in a 35 mile an hour zone. Wow. Near schools, community centers. It's a real safety issue. Yeah, it is. And there was, I think, a fatal motorcycle accident.
[21:00]Yeah. And they had a walk and talk with like a hundred residents to talk about it. Yeah, they're gonna have another meeting to discuss some different options. Yeah. And Rick emphasized that they have to be honest with people about, you know, the cost of change.
[21:14]Yeah. You know, because, you know, there are these quick fixes. Like, you know, just put more police out there. Right. They need to redesign the street. Yeah, which could be more expensive, right? Right. But it might be the right solution in the long run.
[21:27]So, and he closed by sharing this quote. I think it's from World War II, but I'm not sure. It's, out of money, we are going to have to think. Right. You know, like that's kind of where we are now. We can't just keep spending our way out of every problem.
[21:40]Yeah, we have to think creatively. We have to think. We have to innovate. You know, we have to find new ways to do things. And then, and then he referenced Lord Acton's famous quote about power. Yeah. You know? And this less well-known corollary.
[21:55]Right. You know, powerlessness erupts, and absolute powerlessness corrupts. Absolutely. Right. And his argument was that, you know, citizens have been kind of corrupted into thinking that government is just, you know, it's the professional's job.
[22:08]Yeah. It's the politician's job. Just stay home and let us handle it. Yeah, and we have to shift away from that. Right. You know, we have to take more responsibility. We have to be partners. Yeah, it's a partnership. Right. And that's the heart of the strong towns movement.
[22:23]Right. And that's what we're all about here, you know? In Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena, it's- Absolutely. It's hard work, it's slow work, but it's the work that matters. Yeah. So for everybody out there listening, you know, in Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena, we've been talking about how just focusing our efforts locally can empower you.
[22:47]Yeah. To make a difference in your life, in your community, and even small things they can add up, you know, to create big change. Absolutely. So I mean, whether it's, you know, taking the time to look at your local budget, helping out a neighbor, picking up some trash, you know, these little things, if everybody does them, they make a big difference.
[23:07]They really do. And if you find value in what we share here, and you believe in this idea of local action, you know, you can support us. Yeah. Thinkindactlocally.com forward slash donate. You can find the link in the show notes. Right. And as you're going about your week, you know, just think about this.
[23:26]What's one small thing you can do to, you know, be more informed, be more involved in your community. Yeah. Think about that. What's one thing you can do. All right. That's all for this week. Thanks for listening. Yeah. Thanks everybody. See you next time.
[23:40]See you.
