Apr 5, 2025 · 20 min

Rethinking Traffic Safety and Transportation Finance

About this episode

This audio recording captures a keynote address given at a transportation conference in Kansas, where the speaker, Chuck, presents an alternative perspective on traffic safety trends observed during the pandemic. He challenges the prevailing narrative of increased reckless driving, proposing instead that reduced traffic congestion led to higher fatality rates on over-engineered roadways. The speaker introduces the concept of “forgiving design” and its unintended consequences in complex urban environments, advocating for a shift towards prioritizing people over vehicle flow in street design. Furthermore, the address touches upon the unsustainable financial model of transportation infrastructure and the need for a new approach given dwindling resources.

Chapters

  1. Part 1 · 0:00
  2. Part 2 · 5:02
  3. Part 3 · 10:04
  4. Part 4 · 15:01

Transcript

Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.

Part 1 · 0:00

[0:00]Okay, so we're diving into something a little different today. Yeah. We're going to take a deep dive into a presentation about transportation safety and design, and it's based on a keynote address at a statewide transportation conference. This one was in Wichita, Kansas.

[0:15]Right. So we're actually going to be listening to audio recording of the speech. And I will say, just as a heads up, the audio quality can be a little bit uneven at the beginning, but bear with us. I promise the insights you'll gain from it are definitely worth it.

[0:33]So what we're going to try to do today is really pull out the most important ideas about traffic safety and honestly, some surprising downsides of how we design our roads and then also the financial realities that are kind of shaping infrastructure choices.

[0:54]And what we really want to understand is how these broader trends that the speaker talks about might be playing out right here where we live. Right here. In Deer Park, a port and Pasadena. Okay. So thinking locally. Right. Exactly. Exactly.

[1:10]So one of the things that I think is really striking out in the presentation that we're going to listen to today is that the speaker really challenges some of our most basic assumptions about what makes roads safe. Yeah. Like what? Well, he starts off looking at what happened during the pandemic.

[1:31]Interesting. Which as we all know, kind of threw a real wrench in everything. For sure. Including conventional wisdom about traffic safety. Okay. How so? So, I mean, for so long, the thinking has been that fewer cars on the road equals fewer crashes, equals fewer fatalities.

[1:54]Yeah. That's the simple logic, right? Right. Fewer cars, fewer deaths. Yeah. That was sort of the established theory. That's a classic theory. Yeah. And then the pandemic hits and all of a sudden we have this really massive drop in driving.

[2:08]A lot of people staying home. Yeah. People are working from home. People are just staying home, less travel overall. And so you would expect to see with fewer cars on the road. You'd think so. Fewer deaths, right? Fewer accidents, fewer fatalities.

[2:24]Right. But instead... We actually saw an increase in traffic deaths. Oh, that's interesting. Right. So it's like the opposite. It's totally counterintuitive. Yeah. And it really was unexpected. So what happened? Yeah. And so the initial explanation that came from traffic safety officials, as the speaker points out, was basically that all the drivers had just gone crazy, like people were speeding more, not buckling up.

[2:53]Got it. Driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Ah, so they're saying it was just bad driver behavior. Right. It was very much focused on the choices of individual drivers. I see. That they were just behaving badly. So it was the driver's fault.

[3:09]It was kind of like we all collectively decided to become reckless drivers. Pandemic stress, I guess. Maybe it was the stress of the pandemic, who knows. Yeah. But the speaker offers a different perspective. Okay. I'm intrigued. He calls it a more, what does he say, a more scientific way?

[3:29]Yeah, a more scientific way to understand what happened. Interesting. And what's fascinating about his explanation is that it hinges on something that we typically dread. What's that? Traffic congestion. Oh, congestion. Yeah. He suggests that more traffic jams can actually lead to safer roads.

[3:51]And that sounds totally counterintuitive at first. Yeah. I mean, you think more cars, more accidents. Right. And more frustration. Definitely more frustration. But his reasoning is really interesting. Okay. Lay it on me. When you actually dig into it.

[4:05]Yeah, let's unpack this. So the key factor here is speed. Ah, speed. And heavy congestion. You know, everyone is moving very slowly or even completely stopped. Right. Stop and go traffic. And so the potential for serious injury or even death in a collision, it plummets.

[4:25]So the severity goes way down. Way down. Interesting. Because it's just a matter of physics. Due to physics. Right. Lower speeds mean less energy and an impact. Right. Less force involved. Right. And the speaker reminds us that the energy of a moving object increases with the square of its speed.

[4:44]That's right. So even a small reduction in speed can make a huge difference. And how severe a crash is. Gotcha. So the speaker connects this directly to the pandemic. He says that basically with virtually no congestion during the pandemic.

Part 2 · 5:02

[5:02]The roads were empty. Right. Drivers were able to operate on these roads that were designed for much higher speeds, but they were driving at those higher speeds without that natural speed regulator of other vehicles around them. Makes sense.

[5:17]So there's actually some evidence to support this. Like what? As traffic has returned to pre-pandemic levels. In some areas. In a lot of areas. Yeah. We've actually seen a decrease. Oh, wow. In traffic fatalities. So the fatalities are going back down.

[5:34]Right. Which suggests that that return of congestion is playing a role. An unintended role. Right. In safety. In safety. Yeah. Wow. That's wild. The speaker even jokes that some safety initiatives might be getting credit for a decline in fatalities that's simply due to more gridlock.

[5:54]Wow. That's really interesting. Right. Makes you think twice about what really contributes to road safety. For sure. And this kind of leads us to another really thought-provoking concept that the speaker introduces, which is this idea of forgiving design.

[6:15]Forgiving design. Okay. So forgiving design has become really kind of a fundamental principle in modern highway engineering. It's this idea that you design roadways in such a way that if a driver makes a common mistake, the consequences of that mistake are minimized.

[6:34]So they have room for error. Right. Room for error. So if you think back to the early days of motoring, roads were often very narrow, winding, they had hazards like trees or ditches right at the edge of the road. Very unforgiving. Right. Very unforgiving.

[6:50]And so a simple lapse in attention could be disastrous. Absolutely. So forgiving design was really a direct response to that. It was an effort to make roads more tolerant of human error. Okay. So like, what are some examples? Yeah. So the speaker gives some, some good examples.

[7:09]Yeah. Wider lanes, obviously. It's okay. Offer drivers more wiggle room. More room, too. If they drift a little bit. All right. Recovery areas. Recovery areas. So those are like the shoulders. Gotcha. And gentler slopes beside the road. Right, right.

[7:25]Those provide space to regain control if you stray off the pavement. If you go off the road. Right. And then clear zones. So those are those obstacle free areas that allow a vehicle to slow down more safely if it leaves the roadway. So you're not running into a tree.

[7:44]Right. Exactly. So and the speaker is, you know, he's, he's quick to give credit where it's due. Okay. He emphasizes that, you know, there have been significant improvements in highway safety and a dramatic reduction in fatalities per mile traveled over the decades.

[8:05]Over time. Right. Largely thanks to these forgiving design principles. That's right. So, you know, he, he points out that driving on a modern interstate is statistically far safer than it was a century ago. True state. But here's where the speaker throws a curve ball.

[8:24]A curve ball. And this is where it becomes particularly relevant to us here. To our area. Right. In Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena. Okay. So how does this apply locally? Well, he argues that applying the same forgiving design principles in urban environments, in cities, right in cities and towns can actually have some really negative unintended consequences.

[8:51]Oh, so it backfires. In a way. Yeah. It's like a, it's like a double edged sword. Like a double edged sword. Right. So while it, while it enhances safety at high speeds on highways in our towns and cities, it seems to send a different message to driver.

[9:10]Well, you know, all that extra space, those wide open lanes, the absence of immediate visual constraints. Yeah. Nothing blocking your view. Right. It kind of subtly communicates that there's a large margin for error. Like you have space to, to mess up.

[9:26]Right. And, and, and as human beings, we tend to subconsciously take advantage of that perceived safety. I see. So we get more reckless because we feel safer. Yeah. Interesting. So, and this is where the speaker brings in. Brings in what? The work of Daniel Kahneman.

[9:44]Oh yeah. I know him. Right. And his book. Thinking fast and slow. Yeah. Thinking fast and slow. It's a great book. And he talks about, he talks about system one and system two thinking. System two. Okay. Let's not break that down. Okay. Yeah.

[9:57]So system one is like our brain's intuitive, almost automatic mode of thinking.

Part 3 · 10:04

[10:04]Right. Like a gut reaction. Right. Like if you instantly recognize a familiar face. Yeah. Like, oh, I know that person. Right. And then system two is slower, more deliberate, effortful type of thinking. Yeah. Like if you're trying to solve a complex puzzle.

[10:21]Yeah. Or doing your taxes. Right. Exactly. Okay. And so, the speaker's argument is that for most of us. Most of us. Most of the time. Yoast of the time. Yeah. Driving, operating system one. You're not really thinking about it. Right. It's more automatic.

[10:39]We're not consciously calculating every steering input or constantly analyzing every potential hazard. It becomes largely automatic. Right. And so, because of this, he argues that people tend to drive at a speed. At a speed that. That simply feels right and comfortable within the physical environment of the road.

[11:01]Like what the road looks like. Right. Okay. Often, regardless of what the speed limit sign says. Wow. So, when we design a city street. Right. With these wide. Forgiving features. Giving features. That visually resemble a highway. Yeah. Even if the posted speed limit is, you know, 30 miles per hour.

[11:19]30. Our system one thinking kicks in. Yeah. And we drive at a speed. At a speed that. That feels appropriate for that kind of road. So, maybe closer to 45. Right. Maybe 40, 45. Even though it says 30. Exactly. And we've all, we've all experienced that.

[11:35]Right. Yeah, for sure. That disconnect. Yeah. The speaker even mentions this manual on uniform traffic control devices. The MUTCD. Yeah, the MUTCD, which is basically. It's like the. The rule book for road design and signage across the country.

[11:51]Right. And how it doesn't really. It doesn't. Adequately distinguish between the design needs of a high-speed road. Like a highway. Right. And a low-speed urban street. Like a city street. Right. Gotcha. So, this over-engineering. Over. Of our local streets for higher speeds.

[12:09]Right. Combined with these artificially low-posted speed limits. Yeah. Creates what the speaker calls. He calls it a strode. A strode. It's actually a term that he and his organization coined. And I think it really captures this really common problem.

[12:27]This problem. That we see. In our communities. Yeah, in our communities. Yeah. So, think of a strode as a hybrid. Say it here. It's part street. Part street. Part road. Part road. And it's trying to do. It's trying to fundamentally. Oppose things.

[12:43]Okay. At once. Like what? It's trying to move traffic quickly. Okay. Through a place. Yeah. While also functioning as a vibrant urban environment. Oh, that's tough. Right. With businesses. With businesses. Pedestrians. And local access. Yeah.

[13:00]It's like trying to do everything. It's trying to do everything. Yeah. And the speaker has this really great analogy. Yeah, an analogy. Okay. He calls the strode. He calls it. The futon of transportation. Oh, the futon. Right. Yeah. It's, it's uncomfortable.

[13:16]Yeah. And it's failing. It's failing. At both of its intended purposes. At both. Right. It's not efficient at moving large volumes of traffic. Yeah. At speed. At speed. Like a true road. Right. But it's also not a safe or economically productive.

[13:31]Right. Urban street. It's like the worst of both worlds. It is. It's the worst of both worlds. Yeah. And then there's, what's really interesting too, is the financial angle here. Oh, the financial angle. Okay. So while individual businesses.

[13:47]Yeah. That are located on a strove, like a, like a, you know, like a big box store. Like a big Walmart or something. Right. Like a Walmart might generate a significant amount of tax revenue. Yeah. Sales tax, property tax. Right. Sales tax, property tax.

[14:03]Um, the value generated per acre of land in these environments is actually really low. Oh, that's interesting. So this is because so much land is consumed. Consumed by? By all this sprawling infrastructure. Like what kind of infrastructure?

[14:21]You know, massive parking lots. Oh yeah. Huge parking lots. Wide setbacks, multiple lanes. Yeah. Takes up a lot of space. Right. And it just. It's not going to contribute as much. It's not as efficient. To the local economy as, as a dense, walkable urban area.

[14:36]I see. And then, um, yeah, from a safety standpoint. From a safety standpoint. Strode's are, you know, kind of the worst of both worlds in that way too. The worst of both worlds again. Right. Okay. Of the potential. Of the potential. For high speed crashes.

[14:50]Right. From the road aspect of it. Because people are going fast. Right. Yeah. Combined with the complex interactions of pedestrians, cyclists, and turning

Part 4 · 15:01

[15:01]vehicles that you find on a street. Right. So it's like a mixed environment. Right. So it's this dangerous mix. Yeah. Dangerous mix. Where a momentary lapse in attention can have really serious consequences. Yeah, that makes sense. And, um, the speaker emphasizes that the fundamental distinction here.

[15:20]The fundamental distinction. Is between transportation within a place, which is a street. So a street is within a place. Right. Okay. And transportation. And transportation. Between places. Between places. Which is a road. Okay. And he argues that those.

[15:38]Those demands stand. Totally different. Different design approaches. Approaches, yeah. And so, um, this leads to this really important discussion about the long-term financial health of our transportation system. The money. The money, right?

[15:53]And the speaker argues that. He argues that. The era of, you know, seemingly unlimited. Unlimited. Transportation funding. Like free money. Right. Free money. Yeah. That we've kind of grown accustomed to. Yeah. We've just assumed it'll always be there.

[16:08]Right. Yeah. Is coming to an end. Oh, wow. That's scary. Yeah. So it's a pretty, um, significant shift in perspective. Big change. Especially when you think about. Right. When you consider how much economic growth. Yeah. Since World War II.

[16:26]Since World War II. Has been predicated on these massive infrastructure spending projects. Right. We build roads to grow the economy. Right. Exactly. Yeah. So for decades. For decades. Transportation projects have been seen as the primary engine of economic development.

[16:42]The way to grow. Yeah. And the funding taps have seemed. Relatively open. Yeah. Relatively open. Just pour money in. Right. Yeah. But the speaker points to the growing pressures on our transportation networks. So we have, you know, we got an aging population.

[17:00]An aging population. With, with changing needs. Okay. We have younger generations. Younger generations. With different transportation preferences. What? Like. Bikes. Bikes. Walking. Public transit. Public transit. Okay. And then we have. And then we have increasing demand.

[17:16]Demands for. For investments. For investments. And all of those things. Right. Right. In all the new stuff. In all the new stuff. And all of this is happening. In all of this. While our existing infrastructure. Is aging. Is aging and requires increasingly.

[17:28]Costly. Costly maintenance. Yeah. Stuff's wearing out. Yeah. It's wearing out. Gotcha. So he cites data. Data from. From the American Society of Civil Engineers. ECE. ECE. Okay. Yeah. Highlighting a massive shortfall in the funding needed. A shortfall just to maintain.

[17:46]Just to maintain. Our existing interstate highway system. Wow. Just to keep it running? Just to keep it running. That's a lot. And to close that gap. The cap. Through the federal gas tax alone. Yeah. He says it would necessitate. It would take.

[18:02]A truly substantial increase. Like how much? Something on the order of. Like 80 cents a gallon? 80 cents per gallon. Wow. No one's going to like that. Right. And that. That's not. Doesn't even factor in. Yeah. Likely decrease in driving. People would drive less.

[18:17]Right. That would result from such a. From such a price hike. Price hike. Right. Which would further. Which would make it even worse. Erode the funding base. Right. It's like a vicious cycle. Right. Exactly. Yeah. And the speaker. The speaker.

[18:30]Uses this example. Of by. Of the highway 91 expansion. Okay. In California. Yeah. To illustrate how. The traditional methods. Of methods. Of calculating. The benefits. The benefits. Of highway projects. Yeah. Can be. Quite misleading. Misleading?

[18:48]Like how? So they're. They're focused on. These tiny. Tiny. Incremental. Increases. Increases. In rush hour speeds. Like you save two minutes. Right. Like you save a minute or two. Yeah. And then they. And then they. Extrapolate. Right. Those minuscule time savings.

[19:04]Yeah. Yeah. Across huge numbers of drivers. Right. And many years. Many, many years. And so these projects. These projects. Can appear to. Generate these enormous economic benefits. On paper. On paper. Right. That don't necessarily translate into real world improvement.

[19:22]For most people. Right. For most people. It's just a few people benefit. Right. It's a very small number of people who are actually benefiting. Yeah. That's, that's kind of sneaky. It's, it's a little bit sneaky and it reveals this, this potential disconnect.

[19:36]This disconnect.

Related