Public School Versus Homeschooling: A 2019 Comparison
About this episode
A YouTube video transcript examines the debate between public schooling and homeschooling, responding to claims that homeschooling inadequately prepares children. It critiques the increasing federal control and funding of public schools, highlighting stagnant test scores despite rising expenditures. Homeschoolers, in contrast, consistently outperform public school students academically and socially. The video suggests parental involvement and discretionary spending on education contribute to better outcomes. It argues homeschooling offers diverse social interactions and that financial constraints prevent some families from choosing it. Ultimately, the transcript questions the effectiveness of the public school system compared to the personalized approach of homeschooling.
Chapters
Transcript
Machine transcript of the audio. Times are minutes:seconds into the episode.
Part 1 · 0:00
[0:00]All right, everybody, welcome back for another deep dive. Yeah, another deep dive. As you know, we always try to bring you topics that are relevant to folks right here around Deer Park, La Porte, Pasadena. And one of the things that folks always talk about is education.
[0:16]Big one. Public versus private schooling. Huge right here. Charter schools, homeschooling, all that good stuff. So we're gonna dive into a little bit of that today. Okay, sounds good. And specifically, we're gonna be looking at a video that we found over on Mises Media.
[0:30]Okay. And it's kind of a response to this Harvard Law professor. Oh yeah, Elizabeth Bartholet. Yeah, Elizabeth Bartholet. Yeah, she really stirred the pot with this one. Yeah, she's calling for like a near ban on homeschooling. Yeah, she's saying that it goes against- The progressive ideal.
[0:48]The progressive ideals. So that got a lot of people fired up. Yeah, and this is one of those things, I think, that people on both sides of the political spectrum can kind of get behind. There's people on the right who think homeschooling is great.
[1:02]There's people on the left who think homeschooling is great. But there's also people on both sides who think public school is the way to go. Absolutely. So what did Mises Media have to say about all this? Well, they kind of picked apart some of her arguments a little bit.
[1:19]One of the things that she was saying was that public schools are better at teaching civic engagement. Which, you know, that sounds good on the surface. Yeah, what does that mean though? Right, what does that really mean? And do they really do that better?
[1:33]Like is there any evidence to support that? Yeah, and you know what's interesting is the Mises Media video, it kind of goes into the history of public school reform. And you know, we've all heard about no child left behind and all these different initiatives.
[1:46]Right, and billions and billions of dollars spent. Billions with a B, right? I said B. So what was the result of all that? Well, that's kind of the thing they're pointing out is that despite all this money, all these programs, the test scores really haven't gone up appreciably.
[2:02]And they point out a really staggering statistic that taxpayers spend over $155,000 per student in public schools by the time they graduate. Where's all that money going? Well, and that's kind of one of the things that Mises Media is kind of hinting at is that a lot of it goes into this administrative bloat rather than actually in the classroom.
[2:26]Right. You know, you see all these administrators and these different levels of bureaucracy and it just keeps growing and growing. And the teachers are still, you know. Right, the teachers are still underpaid in many cases and the classrooms are overcrowded.
[2:39]So, you mentioned test scores. Let's talk about homeschoolers versus public scores. How do they compare? Well, consistently, homeschoolers score higher on standardized tests. Really? Oh yeah, much higher. Like how much higher are we talking?
[2:52]So about to 30 percentile points. Yeah, that's a big difference. And that's even after, you know, you control for socioeconomic background. Okay, so it's not just that, you know, wealthier kids are being homeschooled and they have all the advantages.
[3:04]Right, exactly. So that's what's the secret sauce there. What are they attributing that to? Well, they point to a couple things. One of them is parental involvement. You know, by its nature, homeschooling requires parents to be much more involved in their kids' education.
[3:22]Right. And also the individualized learning. You know, you can really tailor the curriculum to your child's specific needs and learning style. Right. So, you know, if they're struggling in math, you can spend more time on math. If they're excelling in, you know, history, you can, you know, really dive deep into that.
[3:39]And I guess that kind of leads into the next thing that everybody talks about is socialization. You know, that's always the big argument against homeschooling is that- Right, they're not gonna be socialized. They're not gonna know how to interact with other kids.
[3:51]They're not gonna be, you know, weird and awkward. Right. But what does the research say about that? Well, what's interesting is they actually cite some studies that show that homeschoolers don't really have a problem with socialization. And in fact, some studies show that they may even outperform public schooled kids in some areas of social and emotional development.
[4:09]Okay, so it's not as clear cut as- No, it's not as simple as just saying, oh, they're not gonna be socialized. Right. You know, they're out in the real world. They're interacting with people of all ages. They're not just stuck in a classroom with kids their own age.
[4:22]Right. And they're also often involved in, you know, homeschool co-ops or other activities where they're interacting with other homeschoolers. So they're getting that interaction. They're getting the interaction. But I guess, you know, one of the things that Missus Media brings up is the financial burden of homeschooling.
[4:40]You know, it's not always an option for everybody. Right. You know, you have to be able to afford to have, you know, one parent stay at home or you have to be able to afford to, you know, pay for tutors or curriculum. Right, and that is a big barrier for a lot of families.
[4:54]Right, so it's not a perfect solution by any means. No, it's not a one-size-fits-all solution. All right.
Part 2 · 5:00
[5:00]And, you know, they acknowledge that, you know, there are a lot of families that are stuck in a system that they're not happy with. Right. But they can't afford to get out. And they're still paying for it through their taxes. Exactly. So, you know, it's a complex issue.
[5:12]It is a complex issue. And I think it's important to remember that Mises Media is coming at this from a libertarian perspective. Right. So they're going to be more inclined to advocate for individual choice and less government intervention.
[5:25]Right. But I think they make some valid points. Yeah. You know, about the cost of public education and the effectiveness. And the fact that, you know, there are other options out there that might be a better fit for some families. Right. You know, it's not a one-size-fits-all.
[5:39]Exactly. And, you know, at the end of the day, it's really about what's best for the individual child and the individual family. So, you know, what are your thoughts on this? I mean, what do you think makes a good learning environment for a child?
[5:54]Well, I think that's a great question. And it's something that every parent has to wrestle with. You know, is it about test scores? Is it about socialization? Is it about, you know, critical thinking skills? Right. What are the most important things that you want your child to get out of their education?
[6:08]Right. And, you know, I think a lot of it depends on the child, too. Yeah. Some kids thrive in a traditional classroom setting. Some kids need something a little bit more, you know, individualized. Absolutely. So, you know, there's no easy answer.
[6:23]There's no easy answer. But I think it's a conversation that we need to be having. Absolutely. So, if you're listening out there and you have thoughts on this, we'd love to hear from you. You know, jump on our social media pages. Let us know what you think.
[6:33]Yeah, let us know what you think is important in a good learning environment. And, as always, if you find value in our show, you can support us at thinkandactlocally.com forward slash donate. The link is in the show notes. We really appreciate your support.
